Miller's Merry Manor

    640 W Ellsworth St, Columbia City, IN, 46725
    4.2 · 20 reviews
    • Assisted living
    • Memory care
    • Skilled nursing
    AnonymousLoved one of resident
    4.0

    Caring staff, homey, kitchen concerns

    I toured this facility and felt welcomed - the executive director greeted me and my tour guide Ciera was excellent. Staff (administrator Laurie, RN Sheila, activity planner Amber) were warm, professional, and treated residents like family; the place is clean, homey and being updated despite an older layout. Care was compassionate and seamless for medications, activities are engaging, and staff-resident interactions are strong. The kitchen needs major improvement - vegetables often overcooked to mush, meats dry and hard, bland rice and limited bread options. My experience was largely positive, but I also heard isolated reports of miscommunication and serious medical lapses, so I recommend asking about clinical protocols. Overall, I would recommend this facility for its caring team and comfortable environment.

    Pricing

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    4.20 · 20 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      4.4
    • Staff

      4.2
    • Meals

      2.0
    • Amenities

      4.5
    • Value

      4.2

    Pros

    • Compassionate, attentive, and supportive staff
    • Strong leadership and customer service (Administrator Laurie praised)
    • Skilled nursing presence (RN Sheila named positively)
    • Smooth medication transition after insurance change
    • Active and accessible activities program (Amber noted; bingo accessible)
    • Welcoming tour staff and positive first impressions (Ciera)
    • Clean, newly refurbished rooms and generally odor-free environment
    • Homey, calm, and family-like atmosphere
    • High-quality rehabilitation and healing environment
    • Staff treat residents like family and show extra attention
    • Professionalism, honesty, and knowledgeable team
    • High overall satisfaction and multiple strong recommendations

    Cons

    • Consistently poor food quality and menu preparation
    • Overcooked vegetables and nutrient loss during cooking
    • Dry, hard ground beef and chicken; overcooked patties
    • Bland or plain side items (white rice with no flavor); limited bread options
    • Inconsistent or negligent medical care and miscommunication (serious incidents reported)
    • Delayed medical responses, incorrect vital reporting, and failure to hospitalize promptly
    • Reports of severe adverse outcomes following care (pneumonia, ICU admission, tracheostomy, ventilator dependency, death)
    • Unresponsive or unfriendly staff in some cases; missed callbacks
    • Older building with poor layout in some areas despite updates
    • Mixed impressions on facility comfort and appearance

    Summary review

    Overall sentiment across the reviews is mixed but leans strongly positive about the people who work at Miller's Merry Manor. A large number of reviewers emphasize compassionate, attentive, and professional staff who foster a calm, homelike atmosphere. Administrator Laurie is repeatedly singled out for strong leadership and customer service, and specific staff members such as RN Sheila, activity planner Amber, and tour guide Ciera are named positively. Multiple reviewers describe staff going above and beyond, treating residents like family, providing extra attention, and creating a cohesive community. Rehabilitation services and the broader care team's compassion and competence are also highlighted, with some reviewers explicitly recommending the facility and expressing gratitude for care provided. Several reviews note a seamless medication transition after insurance changes, which points to effective clinical coordination in at least some cases.

    Facilities and environment receive generally favorable remarks with frequent comments about clean, newly refurbished rooms, warm greetings, and an odor-free building. However, reviewers also note that the facility is older in parts and has a suboptimal layout in some areas. These structural issues appear to be mitigated in places by ongoing updates and renovations; nonetheless, impressions of comfort and aesthetics are mixed—some reviewers found the building charming and homey, while others described areas as uncomfortable or poorly designed.

    Activities and social engagement are strengths called out in several summaries. Reviewers appreciate accessible activities such as bingo and the proactive planning by activities staff, contributing to a sense of involvement and community for residents. Positive staff–resident interactions and smiling residents observed during tours were repeatedly mentioned, reinforcing the perception of a friendly, engaged atmosphere.

    Dining is a clear and consistent weakness across many reviews. Multiple reviewers complain of poor food quality and preparation: vegetables overcooked to the point of mush with nutrients leached into cooking liquids, dry and hard ground beef and chicken, overcooked burger patties, bland plain white rice with no flavor or gravy, and limited bread choices dominated by wheat buns instead of more varied options. These specific, repeated complaints indicate the dining program is an area in need of review and improvement.

    A small but critically important subset of reviews raises severe concerns about clinical care, communication, and management. Some reviewers report negligent behavior, miscommunication about medical issues, delays in providing or escalating care, and incorrect vital-sign reporting. In the most serious accounts, reviewers describe delayed hospitalization, subsequent development of pneumonia and ear infection, ICU admission, tracheostomy, ventilator dependency, and death after transfer. These reports contrast sharply with the many positive accounts of caring and competent staff and suggest inconsistent performance or breakdowns in processes in some cases. In addition to these severe allegations, others note unresponsiveness to calls, lack of callbacks, and unfriendly behavior from certain staff members—issues that negatively affect family confidence even when day-to-day care is otherwise acceptable.

    In summary, Miller's Merry Manor appears to offer a strong caregiving culture characterized by compassionate, family-like staff, effective administrators, and active social and rehabilitation programs. Cleanliness and recent refurbishments are noted, and several staff members receive specific praise for their roles. The most prominent areas for improvement are the dining program (with detailed, repeatable criticisms of food quality) and consistency in clinical communication and escalation procedures. The presence of one or more reports describing very serious adverse outcomes following alleged negligence indicates a need for careful review of clinical protocols, staff training, and incident communication to ensure uniformly safe care. Addressing food-service shortcomings and strengthening reliable medical communication and response would likely convert the already-strong staff reputation into a more uniformly positive facility experience.

    Location

    Map showing location of Miller's Merry Manor

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    • Evening view of the entrance area of Belmont Village Senior Living Lincoln Park, featuring brick walls, decorative lighting fixtures, a circular chandelier on the ceiling, and a sign with the facility's name visible near the street.
      $5,506 – $7,157+4.5 (131)
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom • Studio
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Belmont Village Senior Living Lincoln Park

      700 W Fullerton Ave, Chicago, IL, 60614
    • Two-story senior living building with balconies overlooking a large manicured lawn and pond under a blue sky.
      $2,189 – $3,529+4.4 (70)
      Studio • 1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom
      independent living

      StoryPoint Grand Rapids West

      3121 Lake Michigan Drive Northwest, Grand Rapids, MI, 49504
    • Exterior view of Belmont Village Senior Living Glenview building at dusk, showing a large covered entrance with white columns, well-maintained landscaping with bushes and trees, and a multi-story brick and siding facade with lit windows.
      $3,965+4.6 (121)
      Semi-private
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Belmont Village Senior Living Glenview

      2200 Golf Rd, Glenview, IL, 60025
    • Three-story modern senior living building with balconies set behind a grassy lawn and a pond with a fountain.
      $3,000 – $7,000+4.5 (98)
      suite
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      StoryPoint Novi

      42400 W 12 Mile Rd, Novi, MI, 48377
    • Aerial view of a senior living facility named Montage Mason surrounded by green lawns, trees, parking lots, and nearby buildings under a clear sky.
      $4,395 – $5,274+4.5 (75)
      Semi-private
      assisted living, memory care

      Montage Mason

      5373 Merten Dr, Mason, OH, 45040
    • Exterior view of a large, modern three-story senior living facility building with a covered entrance driveway, surrounded by green lawns and trees under a partly cloudy blue sky.
      $5,633 – $7,322+3.9 (69)
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom • Studio
      assisted living, memory care

      Alto Grayslake

      1865 E Belvidere Rd, Grayslake, IL, 60030

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 3 facilities
    2. 0 facilities
    3. 0 facilities
    4. 0 facilities
    5. 3 facilities
    6. 3 facilities
    7. 0 facilities
    8. 0 facilities
    9. 16 facilities$4,142/mo
    10. 3 facilities
    11. 2 facilities
    12. 21 facilities$4,255/mo
    © 2025 Mirador Living