Hickory Creek at Sunset

    1109 S Indiana St, Greencastle, IN 46135
    • Assisted Living
    • Memory Care
    • Skilled Nursing

    Small family-like facility, caring staff

    I'm very pleased with this small, family-like facility - the director and staff are attentive, caring, and know residents by name. My parent receives personalized nursing and therapy, the building is clean and homey, rooms are private, and the food and activities are inviting. Staff respond quickly, go above and beyond, and I would highly recommend this caring team.

    Loved one of resident
    Jul 2026

    Schedule a Tour

    Date of Tour
    Time Window
    Tour Type

    You selected in-person tour on in the

    Amenities

    Healthcare services

    • Activities of daily living assistance
    • Assistance with bathing
    • Assistance with dressing
    • Assistance with transfers
    • Coordination with health care providers
    • Medication management
    • Mental wellness program

    Healthcare staffing

    • 12-16 hour nursing
    • 24-hour call system
    • 24-hour supervision

    Meals and dining

    • Diabetes diet
    • Meal preparation and service
    • Special dietary restrictions

    Room

    • Air-conditioning
    • Cable
    • Fully furnished
    • Housekeeping and linen services
    • Kitchenettes
    • Private bathrooms
    • Telephone
    • Wifi

    Transportation

    • Community operated transportation
    • Transportation arrangement
    • Transportation arrangement (medical)
    • Transportation arrangement (non-medical)
    • Transportation to doctors appointments

    Common areas

    • Beauty salon
    • Computer center
    • Dining room
    • Fitness room
    • Gaming room
    • Garden
    • Outdoor space
    • Small library
    • Wellness center

    Community services

    • Concierge services
    • Fitness programs
    • Move-in coordination

    Activities

    • Community-sponsored activities
    • Planned day trips
    • Resident-run activities
    • Scheduled daily activities

    Reviews

    4.49·(41)

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      4.4
    • Staff

      4.6
    • Meals

      2.6
    • Amenities

      4.2
    • Value

      4.0

    Pros

    • compassionate and attentive caregiving staff
    • staff familiarity with residents' names
    • family-like, home-style atmosphere
    • clean, well-maintained facility
    • private rooms available
    • effective physical and recovery therapy
    • prompt response for medical-equipment needs
    • staff-led activity and engagement efforts
    • supportive admissions and management team
    • thorough cleaning practices and odor-free common areas
    • affordable pricing and small-facility scale

    Cons

    • insufficient staffing coverage
    • delays in responding to resident call systems
    • gaps in fall-prevention and bed-safety practices
    • inconsistent meal quality and service temperature
    • limited flexibility for modified or alternative meal choices
    • variable activity delivery and resident supervision
    • sanitation concerns in some areas
    • inconsistent front-desk coverage and access-control processes
    • staffing retention challenges related to compensation

    Summary of reviews

    Reviewer feedback for Hickory Creek at Sunset presents a mixed but coherent picture: many families praise the staff and the facility's small, home-like environment, while others raise operational concerns that influence day-to-day resident experience. The facility is repeatedly described as clean and well maintained, with staff who know residents by name, offer compassionate care, and foster a family-like atmosphere. Several accounts highlight effective therapy and recovery supports, private-room availability, attentive admissions and management (including specific praise for the director), and prompt provision of medical equipment when needed.

    Care quality and staffing show a clear divergence in perceptions. Positive comments emphasize attentive, kind caregivers and a supportive team that engages residents; however, a number of reviews indicate insufficient staffing coverage and delays in call-system responses. These patterns suggest that while the caregiving culture is strong, staffing levels and responsiveness can be inconsistent, which may affect timely assistance and oversight. There are also concerns about staff compensation and retention that could contribute to variability in coverage.

    Dining experiences are mixed. Some residents and families describe the meals as enjoyable, while others report inconsistent food temperature, heavy reliance on processed or carbohydrate-focused options, and limited accommodations for residents with chewing or texture needs. Operationally, this points to inconsistent meal-service practices and limited flexibility for individualized diet substitutions or modified textures.

    Activity programming is another area of variability. Several reviewers note staff effort to engage residents and organized activities that suit some participants; in contrast, others describe gaps in activity delivery and occasions when residents lacked adequate supervision during planned activities. This suggests the facility attempts active engagement but may not consistently staff or schedule programs to meet all residents' needs.

    Facility and safety observations are largely positive regarding cleanliness and a cozy environment, but reviewers also flagged specific safety and process issues: gaps in fall-prevention and bed-safety practices (including concerns about bed rails and transfer safety), inconsistent front-desk coverage and access-control procedures, and sanitation concerns in particular areas. These operational weaknesses merit direct inspection and discussion during a visit.

    Management and administration earn considerable praise for responsiveness and a supportive admissions process; several families cited a hands-on director and helpful staff in transition and recovery phases. At the same time, a minority of reviews raised serious concerns about staff conduct and sanitation that should be explored further through questions about policies, incident tracking, and oversight.

    Overall, Hickory Creek at Sunset offers a small, personalized setting with many strengths in staff compassion, rehabilitation supports, and a home-like atmosphere. Prospective residents and families should weigh those strengths against reported variability in staffing, response times, meal accommodations, activity consistency, and certain safety/process gaps. Recommended next steps for families: tour during activity periods, review staffing ratios and call-response policies, ask about fall-prevention protocols and dietary accommodation procedures, and request recent inspection or incident logs to assess how the facility addresses the operational issues highlighted by reviewers.

    Reviews written on Mirador

    We have no reviews to show about Hickory Creek at Sunset.

    Help other families by writing a review about your experience with this community.

    Medicare Ratings

    3·/ 5
    • Overall

    • Health Inspection

    • Staffing

    • Quality Measures

    Ratings from the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (Care Compare). View on Medicare.gov

    Location

    Map showing location of Hickory Creek at Sunset

    Hickory Creek at Sunset is located at 1109 S Indiana St, Greencastle, IN, 46135.

    About Hickory Creek at Sunset

    Hickory Creek At Sunset in Greencastle, Indiana is dedicated to creating a welcoming and supportive environment for residents and their families. From the moment you enter the community, you can sense a genuine focus on compassionate care and helping individuals find comfort, answers, and peace of mind. The team at Hickory Creek At Sunset strives to become an extension of each resident’s family, offering not only skilled professional care but also emotional support throughout every stage of the journey.

    A hallmark of Hickory Creek At Sunset is its comprehensive approach to short-term rehabilitation. This service is thoughtfully designed for individuals who are recovering from events such as stroke, orthopedic surgery, cardiovascular difficulties, and other significant health challenges. The goal is to help participants regain their abilities so they can return home safely and continue living life on their own terms. The program encompasses physical, occupational, and speech/language therapies, and is delivered by a collaborative team that includes doctors, nurses, therapists, social workers, and other skilled care professionals. Each plan is personalized, focusing on the individual’s unique motivations and goals to ensure the best possible outcomes. Rehabilitation at Hickory Creek At Sunset is enriched with innovative methodologies and proven techniques, always grounded in respect and compassion.

    For residents who need a more extended level of support, Hickory Creek At Sunset offers long-term care that balances clinical expertise with a nurturing, home-like atmosphere. Under the guidance of an attending physician and supported by licensed nurses and specially trained aides, residents receive a full spectrum of services aimed at maintaining their highest possible level of independence. Physical, occupational, and speech therapies are all integrated as needed, alongside a robust calendar of activities and social engagement opportunities. The setting is intentionally designed to be cheerful, soothing, and secure, helping residents feel safe and at ease as they make the community their home. There are multiple payment options available, and specialists are available to help with the necessary application processes, making the transition as seamless as possible for families.

    Understanding the challenges and responsibilities faced by family caregivers, Hickory Creek At Sunset also provides senior respite care. This option is ideal for those who need temporary support, whether to recover from an illness, travel, or simply to take a well-deserved break. The needs of respite guests are carefully assessed to ensure that every individual receives the appropriate level of care and comfort. Stays can be short or extended, depending on each unique situation. The peace of mind that comes from knowing a loved one is well cared for in a supportive setting allows family caregivers to tend to their own wellbeing without concern.

    End-of-life care at Hickory Creek At Sunset is handled with exceptional dignity, compassion, and respect. The hospice and palliative care program is focused on providing comfort, effective pain management, and meeting the emotional and spiritual needs of both the resident and their family. An interdisciplinary team combines skilled nursing, spiritual counseling, social services, and bereavement support to create a holistic approach during this significant stage of life. Comprehensive resources and support are in place to help families and residents navigate these moments with assurance, care, and comfort.

    Hickory Creek At Sunset is more than a care facility; it is a vibrant community with a deeply rooted philosophy of resident-centered care. Every aspect of its service—from therapy and wellness programs to everyday activities and clinical support—is designed to enhance the quality of life, promote independence, and nurture meaningful connections for each individual. The caring atmosphere, along with robust wellness and rehabilitation initiatives, ensures that every resident at Hickory Creek At Sunset receives the best possible experience tailored to their personal needs and aspirations.

    People often ask...

    Hickory Creek at Sunset offers assisted living, memory care, and skilled nursing.

    There are 5 photos of Hickory Creek at Sunset on Mirador.

    The full address for this community is 1109 S Indiana St, Greencastle, IN 46135.

    No, Hickory Creek at Sunset does not offer respite care. Respite care in assisted living communities provides temporary, short-term relief for primary caregivers by offering professional care for their loved ones. It allows individuals to stay in an assisted living community for a limited time, giving caregivers a break while ensuring residents receive necessary support and assistance with daily activities.

    Disclaimer

    Mirador Living is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of Hickory Creek at Sunset. The information above has not been verified or approved by the owner or operator. For exact information, please contact Hickory Creek at Sunset directly. There is no cost for this service. We are compensated by the community you select.

    Are you an owner or operator of this community?

    Claim this listing to receive messages from prospective customers and manage your community page.

    Nearby Communities

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 5 facilities$5,072/mo
    2. 2 facilities
    3. 7 facilities$7,065/mo
    4. 7 facilities$7,065/mo
    5. 7 facilities$7,065/mo
    6. 7 facilities$7,065/mo
    7. 19 facilities$5,950/mo
    8. 7 facilities$7,065/mo
    9. 5 facilities
    10. 22 facilities$5,443/mo
    11. 2 facilities
    12. 3 facilities
    © 2026 Mirador Living