Abbey-Assisted Living

    9415 Johnnycake Ridge Rd, Mentor, OH, 44060
    3.3 · 4 reviews
      AnonymousLoved one of resident
      3.0

      Excellent care but unsafe, inaccessible

      I appreciate the compassionate, competent medical care here - the staff live on-site, are patient and knowledgeable, keep things clean, avoid over-medicating, provide well-planned nutritious meals, and PT updates me regularly. But the place is poorly accessible: steps and awkward ramps make walkers/wheelchairs difficult, rooms can hold up to three people and aren't wheelchair-friendly, smoking is allowed inside, and my mom even fell. There are almost no planned activities and it's noisy with kids and animals, so residents mostly sit and watch TV. Overall: excellent hands-on care, but serious issues with safety, accessibility, and stimulation.

      Pricing

      Schedule a Tour

      Amenities

      3.25 · 4 reviews

      Overall rating

      1. 5
      2. 4
      3. 3
      4. 2
      5. 1
      • Care

        5.0
      • Staff

        5.0
      • Meals

        4.0
      • Amenities

        2.0
      • Value

        3.3

      Pros

      • compassionate caretaking
      • competent medical care and attention
      • home-like atmosphere
      • well-planned, nutritious meals
      • evident cleanliness
      • no over-medication
      • knowledgeable and patient staff
      • staff who go above and beyond
      • regular updates from physical therapist

      Cons

      • very loud environment
      • staff live on-site creating family noise
      • children and animals present in facility
      • safety concern: resident fall reported
      • not wheelchair accessible
      • wheelchairs require assistance to push
      • many steps throughout facility
      • residents bored, mostly watching TV
      • no scheduled or planned activities
      • steps and ramps difficult for walkers
      • smoking allowed inside the house
      • up to three residents per bedroom (crowding)

      Summary review

      Overall sentiment from the reviews is mixed but leans toward strong praise for direct caregiving and clinical attention, paired with clear and repeated concerns about the physical environment, accessibility, noise and activity programming. Multiple reviewers emphasize that the frontline caregiving team is compassionate, knowledgeable and patient. Comments highlight competent medical attention, explicit praise for not over-medicating residents, and appreciation for communication from the physical therapist. The caregiving culture is described as home-like and clean, with staff who often go above and beyond routine duties. Dining is repeatedly called out as a positive aspect — meals are described as well-planned and nutritious, contributing to a homey, attentive care impression.

      At the same time, there are consistent, substantive negatives related to the facility itself and resident experience beyond one-on-one care. Several reviewers describe the environment as very loud; the presence of staff families living on-site, including children and animals, is noted as a source of noise and disruption. This blending of a private household atmosphere with an assisted living setting appears to create situations that some family members find inappropriate for a senior care environment. In at least one instance a fall is reported, which raises safety concerns in combination with other environmental issues.

      Accessibility and physical layout are major recurring problems. The facility is reported as not wheelchair accessible in practice — wheelchairs require assistance to be pushed, and there are steps and ramps throughout that are difficult for walkers. These details indicate that mobility-impaired residents may struggle to move independently and that the property is not well-adapted for people with reduced mobility. Smoking being allowed inside the house and reports of up to three residents sharing a bedroom raise additional health, safety and comfort concerns; crowding and indoor smoking are important risk factors for vulnerable seniors.

      Social programming and residents’ day-to-day stimulation are another consistent area of concern. Multiple comments indicate boredom among residents, with many reported to be passively watching TV and no planned activities in evidence. This suggests limited structured social, cognitive or physical programming, which can negatively affect quality of life even where clinical care is good. The combination of limited activities, a noisy household atmosphere, and accessibility barriers paints a picture where residents may receive good personal care but lack an appropriate, safe and engaging living environment.

      Management and operational patterns appear mixed: reviewers perceive staff as caring and clinically competent, yet operational choices — permitting on-site staff living with families (including children and pets), allowing indoor smoking, and accommodating multiple residents per bedroom — create significant trade-offs. These management decisions seem to prioritize a homelike, informal model that works well for some aspects (cleanliness, meals, compassionate care) but introduces noise, potential infection/safety risks, and structural barriers that are problematic for many residents and families.

      In summary, the reviews describe a facility with clearly strong interpersonal and clinical caregiving strengths — compassionate staff, good medical attention, nutritious meals and cleanliness — but with important and recurring weaknesses in physical accessibility, noise and household activity, resident safety and social programming. Prospective families should weigh the apparent excellence in personal care and mealtime/nursing attention against the practical drawbacks: limited wheelchair/walker accessibility, a loud household environment with children and pets, smoking indoors, potential crowding in bedrooms, and a lack of organized activities. These trade-offs result in a facility that may be a good fit for residents who need attentive medical care in a home-like setting and are mobile/independent enough to navigate the physical layout, but less appropriate for residents who require strong accessibility features, quieter surroundings, smoke-free air, or robust day programming.

      Location

      Map showing location of Abbey-Assisted Living

      About Abbey-Assisted Living

      Abbey-Assisted Living sits in Mentor, Ohio, close to Cleveland and surrounded by natural places like Mentor Marsh and Headlands Beach State Park, so residents can get outside for walks, bird watching, and fresh air pretty easily, and folks can also visit nearby shopping, restaurants, and doctors whenever they need. This facility has space for up to sixteen people, which keeps things quiet and encourages friendships among everyone living there, and the building, built back in 1920, gives off an old-fashioned and welcoming feeling that's nice for folks who want something homey. The community mainly offers assisted living, which works well for folks who want to keep their independence but need some help with daily chores like bathing, medication, or eating, and caregivers handle tasks with a one to five staff-to-resident ratio, making sure everyone gets noticed and cared for. They help with memory care for those dealing with Alzheimer's, plus there's support for wound care, incontinence, and all kinds of personal needs. For medical issues, they've got a doctor on call, a visiting nurse, and other therapists like podiatrists and dentists, and there's on-site home health care and hospice care including Medicare-certified services. Emergency needs are covered with trained practitioners and registered nurses on-site around the clock, and adults as young as 40 can live here if they need this kind of help.

      Meals are included, served three times a day with a focus on nutrition and quality, and dining has been recognized for being quite good, while residents have the freedom to decorate and arrange rooms how they like, which adds comfort and lets everyone put their own touch on things. Both men and women aged 40 or older can apply, and living units have step-free showers and enough space for wheelchairs or walkers to make moving around easier, plus air conditioning and heating are built in so everyone can stay safe and comfortable, whether it's hot or cold out. Pets can live here, indoor and outdoor common areas are accessible, and parking's set aside for folks and their visitors. Folks have access to activities, both in the building and out, and there's free cable TV, wireless internet, and even an on-site beautician, so there's no need to go far for a haircut or a bit of pampering. Different care arrangements are possible, from temporary respite care, which gives family caregivers a break, to long-term residential support, or adult day services.

      There's a smoke-free policy in all inside spaces, which keeps the air clean for everyone. Residents often join in devotional activities, wellness events, or recreational outings in the community, so days can be both busy and fun, but quiet times are easy to find too, thanks to the smaller size. For those looking for peace and help, but not a busy or crowded environment, Abbey-Assisted Living lets folks keep some independence while always knowing support is close by. Prices haven't been shared publicly, but local averages usually run between $5,135 and $5,453 per month depending on the services needed.

      People often ask...

      Nearby Communities

      • Front entrance of a brick multi-story building with a covered porte-cochère and a 'Brookdale' sign above the doors.
        $3,448 – $4,482+4.7 (112)
        Semi-private • Studio
        independent living, assisted living

        Brookdale Mt. Lebanon

        1050 McNeilly Rd, Pittsburgh, PA, 15226
      • Outdoor entrance sign reading 'Sunrise Senior Living' mounted on a white picket fence with surrounding landscaping.
        $3,760 – $4,512+3.9 (101)
        Semi-private
        assisted living, memory care

        River Oaks Assisted Living & Memory Care

        500 E University Dr, Rochester, MI, 48307
      • Three-story modern senior living building with balconies set behind a grassy lawn and a pond with a fountain.
        $3,000 – $7,000+4.5 (98)
        suite
        independent, assisted living, memory care

        StoryPoint Novi

        42400 W 12 Mile Rd, Novi, MI, 48377
      • Aerial view of a senior living facility named Montage Mason surrounded by green lawns, trees, parking lots, and nearby buildings under a clear sky.
        $4,395 – $5,274+4.5 (75)
        Semi-private
        assisted living, memory care

        Montage Mason

        5373 Merten Dr, Mason, OH, 45040
      • Two-story senior living building with balconies overlooking a large manicured lawn and pond under a blue sky.
        $2,189 – $3,529+4.4 (70)
        Studio • 1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom
        independent living

        StoryPoint Grand Rapids West

        3121 Lake Michigan Drive Northwest, Grand Rapids, MI, 49504
      • Exterior view of a large, multi-story senior living facility building at dusk with lights on inside. In the foreground, there is a landscaped area with a sign that reads 'Legend Personal Care Memory Care' and the number 425. The building has multiple windows and a sloped roof.
        $5,725 – $7,442+4.3 (30)
        Semi-private • 1 Bedroom • Studio
        assisted living, memory care

        Legend at Silver Creek

        425 Lambs Gap Rd, Mechanicsburg, PA, 17050

      Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

      1. 64 facilities$5,921/mo
      2. 54 facilities$5,554/mo
      3. 55 facilities$5,554/mo
      4. 43 facilities$5,611/mo
      5. 48 facilities$5,815/mo
      6. 34 facilities$5,668/mo
      7. 67 facilities$5,996/mo
      8. 30 facilities$5,506/mo
      9. 59 facilities$5,909/mo
      10. 26 facilities$5,506/mo
      11. 57 facilities$6,016/mo
      12. 51 facilities$6,032/mo
      © 2025 Mirador Living