Albany Apartments

    33 N 58th St, Mesa, AZ, 85205
    3.4 · 5 reviews
    • Independent living
    AnonymousCurrent/former resident
    2.0

    Cute apartment, messy move-in, unresponsive

    I liked the cute, quiet apartment, good layout, easy parking and friendly neighbors, but my move-in was a mess: the unit wasn't cleaned or painted, wires were hanging, and an appliance I paid for was never installed. Management and maintenance were slow and unresponsive - multiple repairs and promises are still pending. I can't recommend it until management and upkeep improve.

    Pricing

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    3.40 · 5 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      3.4
    • Staff

      3.0
    • Meals

      3.4
    • Amenities

      5.0
    • Value

      3.0

    Pros

    • Cute apartments
    • Quiet neighborhood
    • Well maintained (in some units)
    • Good layout
    • Accessible — no stairs
    • Open living spaces
    • Sense of security
    • Peaceful environment
    • Well‑laid out parking
    • Reasonable pricing
    • In-unit washer/dryer
    • Responsive management (in some cases)
    • Helpful maintenance staff (in some cases)
    • Clean and well-lit units (reported)
    • Friendly neighbors
    • Family-friendly recommendation

    Cons

    • Inconsistent/poor management (reports of mismanagement)
    • Delayed or incomplete maintenance
    • Units not cleaned before move-in
    • Hanging wires/visible safety issues
    • Appliances promised but not installed or delivered
    • Mismanaged or rushed walkthroughs
    • Apartment not ready at move-in (unfinished painting, pending repairs)
    • Unfulfilled promises from management
    • Some reviewers advise avoiding the property
    • Maintenance and readiness vary between units

    Summary review

    Overall sentiment across the review summaries is mixed: many reviewers praise the physical property and location, but a significant minority report serious operational and management problems that materially affect move-in experience and ongoing satisfaction. Positive comments cluster around the apartment design and neighborhood — reviewers commonly mention 'cute' apartments, good layouts and open living spaces, single-level accessibility (no stairs), peaceful surroundings and a sense of security, along with well-laid out parking. Several summaries also highlight reasonable pricing and practical amenities such as in-unit washer/dryer. Where the property performs well, reviewers describe units as clean, well-lit, well-maintained, with helpful maintenance staff and responsive management, and they would recommend the community to families.

    However, a prominent and recurring theme is inconsistency in management and maintenance. Multiple summaries recount management issues ranging from mismanaged walkthroughs to unfulfilled promises. There are specific, concrete complaints about units not being ready for move-in — paint unfinished, repairs pending, units not cleaned, wires hanging from walls, and appliances that were promised (and paid for) but not installed or delivered. Some reviewers describe delayed maintenance and poor follow-through by staff, which contrasts directly with other reviews that call the management responsive. This variability indicates that experiences may depend heavily on timing, specific units, or which staff members are on duty.

    Staff performance and care quality (interpreting 'care quality' here as responsiveness to tenant needs and maintenance) therefore appear uneven. Where staff and maintenance are responsive, tenants report a positive living experience: repairs are completed, maintenance is helpful, and management communicates effectively. Where staff fall short, tenants report a mismanaged move-in process, pending repairs, and lingering safety/ cleanliness issues. There is no consistent report about dining or activities — these aspects are not mentioned in the summaries — so no conclusions can be drawn about community programming or on-site services beyond maintenance and management responsiveness.

    Facilities themselves are praised when they are in proper order: the layout, accessibility, parking, and general neighborhood reputation are clear strengths. Physical safety concerns are raised only in the context of poor maintenance (for example, hanging wires), which suggests the facility's infrastructure can be fine but occasionally neglected. Pricing is described as reasonable by multiple reviewers, which combined with the favorable physical attributes may make the property attractive — provided the unit is delivered in promised condition.

    Notable patterns and recommendations for prospective renters: the strongest pattern is variability. Some tenants experience a smooth, well-managed property; others encounter serious move-in and maintenance problems. Because of that split, anyone considering Albany Apartments should prioritize an in-person, thorough walkthrough immediately before lease signing and again immediately prior to move-in. Confirm in writing which appliances and repairs are to be completed and get target completion dates. Inspect for cleanliness, paint, exposed wiring, and installed appliances; if anything is outstanding, obtain written commitments and a clear timeline. Ask current residents about recent responsiveness of management and maintenance to gauge whether the unit or building you are considering has been well maintained.

    In summary, Albany Apartments offers many appealing physical and neighborhood qualities — cute, well-laid-out units in a quiet, safe area with good parking and reasonable prices — but prospective residents should be cautious and verify unit readiness and management commitments in writing because of repeated reports of inconsistent management, delayed or incomplete maintenance, and move-in readiness problems. Where management and maintenance are effective tenants report a happy living experience; where they are not, the issues can be substantial enough that some reviewers advise avoiding the property.

    Location

    Map showing location of Albany Apartments

    About Albany Apartments

    Albany Apartments sits at 33 N 58th Street in Mesa, AZ, and offers a senior living option where you can choose a one or two-bedroom floor plan, and the whole place runs as single-story townhome apartments so you don't need to worry about stairs, and each unit has its own washer and dryer, which does make laundry easier, though you won't find a dishwasher in these kitchens, but the kitchens themselves are all-electric and everything has central air and heating, and every apartment comes with ceiling fans and wood grain vinyl flooring, which is easy to clean. Some units are made accessible, and you can step out onto your own patio or balcony if you like fresh air, and residents have covered parking, which is convenient, and the whole community is pet-friendly so people who have a dog or a cat are welcome. The facility is managed by NorthStar Management and Consulting Inc., who seem to take care of things well, and residents have said the community stays clean and well maintained, and you can expect a quiet place where people live independently but also get support if they need help with things like bathing, dressing, or medication. Albany Apartments doesn't have a pool or dishwashers, but it does focus on helping make daily life easier for residents, with a staff that's committed to equal housing and resident satisfaction, and there are different amenities and some planned activities that try to keep people socially and mentally active, making it a simple, comfortable spot for seniors who want peace of mind and a stress-free living environment.

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    • Entrance sign reading 'McDowell Village West Wing' amid desert landscaping with cacti and the apartment building under a blue sky.
      $5,200 – $6,500+4.7 (107)
      1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom
      independent living, assisted living

      McDowell Village

      8300 East McDowell Road, Scottsdale, AZ, 85257
    • Exterior view of a multi-story senior living facility building with white walls and red-tiled roof accents. The foreground features a landscaped area with bushes and a sign that reads 'Gardens Care Scottsdale' along with a phone number. Several cars are parked near the building under a covered area.
      $2,249 – $4,000+4.1 (98)
      Studio • 1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom • Semi-private
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Gardens Care Senior Living - Scottsdale

      9185 E Desert Cove Ave, Scottsdale, AZ, 85260
    • Exterior view of Maravilla Scottsdale senior living community building with a beige stucco wall and illuminated sign reading 'Maravilla Scottsdale An SRG Senior Living Community' surrounded by desert landscaping and trees at dusk.
      Pricing on request4.6 (98)
      suite
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Maravilla Scottsdale

      7325 E Princess Blvd, Scottsdale, AZ, 85255
    • Front exterior of a two-story Mediterranean-style senior living building with a covered driveway and illuminated windows at dusk.
      $3,825 – $4,475+4.4 (110)
      1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom
      independent living, assisted living

      La Siena

      909 E Northern Ave, Phoenix, AZ, 85020
    • Exterior view of Amber Lights senior living community with a large sign displaying the name and address, surrounded by landscaped greenery, palm trees, and desert plants under a clear blue sky.
      $3,530+3.8 (57)
      1 Bedroom
      independent living, assisted living

      Amber Lights

      6231 N Montebella Rd, Tucson, AZ, 85704
    • Exterior view of Atria Rancho Mirage senior living facility with tall palm trees in front, a covered entrance, and beige buildings with tiled roofs under a clear blue sky.
      $2,895 – $6,095+4.3 (183)
      Studio
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Atria Rancho Mirage

      34560 Bob Hope Dr, Rancho Mirage, CA, 92270

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 279 facilities$4,599/mo
    2. 227 facilities$4,608/mo
    3. 95 facilities$3,665/mo
    4. 75 facilities$3,303/mo
    5. 309 facilities$4,086/mo
    6. 52 facilities$4,135/mo
    7. 55 facilities$4,117/mo
    8. 202 facilities$4,635/mo
    9. 32 facilities$5,245/mo
    10. 181 facilities$4,810/mo
    11. 5 facilities$3,902/mo
    12. 148 facilities$3,844/mo
    © 2025 Mirador Living