The Cottages at Garden Grove

    5411 Meltzer Ct, Cicero, NY, 13039
    3.5 · 92 reviews
    • Assisted living
    • Memory care
    • Skilled nursing
    AnonymousLoved one of resident
    2.0

    Great therapy, major staffing problems

    I appreciated the bright, private rooms and the excellent OT/PT - many aides were compassionate and helpful. But I saw chronic understaffing, inattentive or untrained CNAs, nurses who ignored complaints, medication errors and poor communication from management. The food was often bad, bathroom help and basic care were delayed, and safety lapses led to falls, hospitalizations and serious injuries for some residents. End-of-life coordination and wound/medical care felt inconsistent and, at times, neglected. Beautiful facility with great therapy and some wonderful staff, but major staffing and nursing problems make me wary of long-term placement.

    Pricing

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    Healthcare services

    • Activities of daily living assistance
    • Assistance with bathing
    • Assistance with dressing
    • Assistance with transfers
    • Medication management
    • Mental wellness program

    Healthcare staffing

    • 12-16 hour nursing
    • 24-hour call system
    • 24-hour supervision

    Meals and dining

    • Diabetes diet
    • Meal preparation and service
    • Restaurant-style dining
    • Special dietary restrictions

    Room

    • Air-conditioning
    • Cable
    • Fully furnished
    • Housekeeping and linen services
    • Kitchenettes
    • Private bathrooms
    • Telephone
    • Wifi

    Transportation

    • Community operated transportation
    • Transportation arrangement
    • Transportation arrangement (non-medical)

    Common areas

    • Beauty salon
    • Computer center
    • Dining room
    • Fitness room
    • Gaming room
    • Garden
    • Outdoor space
    • Small library
    • Wellness center

    Community services

    • Concierge services
    • Fitness programs
    • Move-in coordination

    Activities

    • Community-sponsored activities
    • Planned day trips
    • Resident-run activities
    • Scheduled daily activities

    3.48 · 92 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      2.9
    • Staff

      2.9
    • Meals

      2.1
    • Amenities

      3.9
    • Value

      1.3

    Pros

    • Clean, modern/new facility and cottages
    • Private rooms with private bathrooms and showers
    • Small, home-like cottage model (13-resident cottages)
    • Many compassionate, attentive aides and nurses praised
    • Several staff members and administrators singled out as caring
    • Helpful, effective physical and occupational therapy in many cases
    • Good rehabilitation services reported by multiple reviewers
    • Large rooms and handicap-accessible bathrooms
    • Screened-in porches, patios, backyard and pleasant grounds
    • Open kitchen and in-cottage meal service in some locations
    • Posted daily activities and presence of a recreation director in some cottages
    • Quiet, peaceful, relaxed environment with community feel
    • Consistent caregiver assignments when staffing is stable
    • High-quality care compared to other regional centers per some reviewers
    • Flexible and accommodating staff during admissions and transitions
    • Attentive wound care reported in several positive experiences
    • Comfortable, cozy rooms and welcoming décor
    • Family-friendly location and proximity to relatives
    • Some cottages provide an a la carte meal option and alternative meal choices
    • Some reviewers would recommend and would return for care

    Cons

    • Severe and chronic understaffing (including nights and weekends)
    • Long wait times for assistance with toileting and transfers
    • Inconsistent staff performance and high turnover
    • Use of agency or undertrained aides who are rough or uncaring
    • Frequent reports of neglect (left in wet diapers, not cleaned, not fed)
    • Multiple allegations of verbal abuse, hostility, and poor interactions
    • Medication errors and incorrect blood sugar testing
    • Reports of overmedication, excessive sedation, or unconsented medications
    • End-of-life protocols or changes without family/guardian permission
    • Poor communication and phone responsiveness from staff/administration
    • Management perceived as lip service or overwhelmed; nurse manager overloaded
    • Failure to follow care plans and poor guardian notification
    • Inadequate or inconsistent therapy continuity in some cases
    • Limited, inconsistent, or poorly implemented activities program
    • Food quality complaints: repetitive, poor taste, often catered or prepared by staff
    • Safety incidents: falls, hip dislocation, wounds, unexplained burns/abrasions
    • Delayed or problematic hospital transfers and discharge coordination
    • Unclear or mishandled wound/bedsore assessments
    • Inconsistent cleanliness/maintenance in some cottages (bugs, dirty toilets)
    • Staff unprofessionalism (gossiping, texting/phones during care, inappropriate visitors)
    • Nurses/administration perceived as hiding behind locked doors or unresponsive
    • Reports of basic needs not met (no snacks/juice, no in-room assistance)
    • Some reviewers reported patient decline or death following poor care
    • High cost for perceived poor value in some negative reports
    • Inconsistent meal preparation (meals brought in/not prepared on-site)

    Summary review

    Overall sentiment across the reviews for The Cottages at Garden Grove is strongly mixed, with a clear polarity: many families and residents report genuinely excellent, compassionate, and attentive care in a beautiful, small-cottage environment, while a substantial number report serious lapses in staffing, safety, communication, and basic care. The facility's physical design and concept—a newer, home-like set of small cottages with private rooms, private bathrooms, screened porches, and pleasant outdoor areas—receive frequent praise. Multiple reviewers highlight the comfort, accessibility, and aesthetics of the buildings, and many note that the small size encourages familiarity between residents and regular caregivers when staffing allows. When staffing and management are functioning well, reviewers commonly describe individualized care, strong rehabilitation outcomes, and staff who go above and beyond during difficult family situations.

    Care quality and staffing are the most recurring and consequential themes. Positive reviews often single out attentive aides, skilled nurses, and effective PT/OT services; some reviewers credit specific staff and social workers by name for helpful support. These accounts emphasize consistent caregivers, meaningful rehabilitation progress, responsive wound care, and professional admission and discharge coordination. In contrast, the negative reports center on chronic understaffing—especially at night and on weekends—high turnover, and an overreliance on agency or undertrained aides. These staffing shortfalls are linked repeatedly to long waits for toileting/assistance, residents being left in wet or soiled garments, inadequate feeding support, and instances of falls or injuries that families attribute to lack of timely help.

    Safety, neglect, and clinical management emerge as critical concerns in a notable subset of reviews. There are multiple alarming allegations: medication errors (including wrong blood sugar testing), overmedication/sedation without consent, end-of-life decisions or protocols enacted without proper family or guardian involvement, and failure to connect or coordinate with outside physicians. Several reviewers report severe adverse outcomes such as hip dislocation requiring surgery, bedsore mismanagement, unexplained bruises, burns or abrasions, and at least a few cases where a resident declined and later died amid complaints about delays in care or poor assessment. Instances of alleged verbal abuse, hostility, and unprofessional conduct by some staff add to the safety concerns. These reports suggest that when staffing and oversight are insufficient, clinical risks and neglect can follow.

    Operations, management, and communication are other recurrent problem areas. Many reviewers describe poor phone responsiveness, delayed messages, and difficulty reaching staff or clarifying care plans. Families report that management sometimes appears overwhelmed or gives lip service without corrective action; nurse managers are described in some accounts as overloaded. Other operational issues include inconsistent therapy scheduling and continuity, inconsistent implementation of recreation plans, and occasional confusion about admissions logistics (e.g., unmarked offices or locked doors delaying entry). On the positive side, some reviewers found admissions simple and staff accommodating, indicating variability across cottages and shifts.

    Dining, activities, and daily life show mixed feedback but trend negative in multiple reports. Food quality is one of the most commonly cited negatives: reviewers frequently describe meals as repetitive, bland, or poorly prepared (with reports of heavily catered or nurse/aide-prepared food rather than a dedicated cook), and complaints about lack of snacks or beverages between meals. Activity programming receives mixed notes—some cottages have posted activities, bingo, music, outings, and a recreation director, while others report almost no activities, residents forced to sit idle in wheelchairs for extended periods, and recreation plans that are not implemented. When programs are active and staffed, families appreciate the community-style outings and social environment.

    Cleanliness and maintenance receive mostly positive mentions regarding the facility's appearance and modern standards, but there are multiple counterexamples describing pests (ants, flies), dirty toilets, and housekeeping lapses requiring family intervention. Professionalism concerns (staff gossiping, being on phones or texting during care, letting unvetted visitors in) recur in negative reviews and contribute to impressions of inconsistent supervision and culture.

    Patterns across reviews point to variability between cottages, shifts, and individual staff members. Many families report very positive experiences with named staff and particular cottages, while others record severe negative incidents tied to understaffed shifts or temporary agency aides. This variability suggests that the facility's concept and physical environment are strong assets, but delivery of safe, consistent care depends heavily on staffing levels, staff training, supervision, and management follow-through. Several reviews explicitly encourage prospective families to verify staffing ratios, night coverage, medication handling protocols, wound-care competence, end-of-life decision policies, and the source/preparation of meals during a tour.

    In summary, The Cottages at Garden Grove presents a compelling, high-quality physical environment and model of small, home-like cottages that can deliver excellent, individualized care when staffing and management function effectively. However, a significant and recurring set of complaints—severe understaffing, communication failures, medication and clinical management errors, neglectful incidents, and inconsistent food and activity programming—raise substantive safety and quality concerns for a nontrivial portion of residents. Families considering this community should weigh the facility's strong positives against documented risks, ask specific operational and clinical questions during tours, request recent staffing and inspection records, and consider monitoring arrangements (frequent visits, clear communication protocols) if choosing this provider.

    Location

    Map showing location of The Cottages at Garden Grove

    About The Cottages at Garden Grove

    The Cottages at Garden Grove provides senior living with several care options, covering independent living, assisted living, memory care, and skilled nursing. The community has small, 13-person care homes called The Cottages, each with private bedrooms and baths, so every resident gets privacy and personal space, and these homes are set up to feel like a regular house rather than a big institution, with spaces like the Beautiful Kitchen and the Hearth Room where people can gather and spend time together if they want to. Skilled nursing services are available 24 hours a day, including rehabilitation, wound care, and medical oversight, while assisted living covers help with things like meals, personal care, and managing medicine, so nobody has to worry about basics if they're having trouble. For those with memory problems, there are secure environments and special programs, along with memory-enhancing activities, so seniors get the right supervision and support. The Cottages at Garden Grove focuses strongly on safety, comfort, and independence, using the latest technology in daily routines and having a team always available for help. The community is designed to support people after surgeries or health setbacks with skilled care and short-term rehab, but it also offers a maintenance-free lifestyle and resort-style social activities for more active seniors who just want fewer worries. Distinct areas for dining, wellness, and recreation mean people can choose quiet time or social time, and optional supports are there as needed. Culture-specific and themed residences offer more personal touches, while respite care is an option for temporary stays. Everything from walking paths to secure memory care units and meal services in the Beautiful Kitchen helps create a homey setting that encourages independence but doesn't forget the need for constant support, and more details are available anytime at cottagesatgardengrove.org.

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    • Front exterior view of The Bristal Assisted Living at Wayne building with a covered entrance, a white car parked under the canopy, surrounded by trees and landscaping under a blue sky with some clouds.
      $4,500+4.1 (51)
      1 Bedroom
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      The Bristal Assisted Living at Wayne

      1440 Hamburg Tpke, Wayne, NJ, 07470
    • Street-level view of a multi-story brick and glass high-rise with large windows and people and cars at the sidewalk.
      $17,000 – $23,450+4.5 (31)
      Studio • 1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom • Semi-private
      assisted living, memory care

      The Apsley

      2330 Broadway, New York, NY, 10024
    • A woman in a red dress and red face mask playing the violin while another woman in a black dress plays a grand piano in a room with wooden paneled walls and abstract artwork hanging behind them.
      $15,000 – $25,000+4.8 (47)
      Studio • 1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom
      assisted living

      Inspīr Carnegie Hill

      1802 2nd Ave, New York, NY, 10128
    • Tall modern high-rise with a glass and brown facade at a city street intersection.
      $10,800 – $25,500+4.4 (86)
      Studio • 1 Bedroom • 2 Bedroom
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Coterie Hudson Yards

      505 W 35th St, New York, NY, 10001
    • A tall, modern multi-story building with many windows reflecting sunlight, situated on a city street at sunset with people crossing the street and cars parked along the road.
      $8,900 – $15,600+4.7 (72)
      Studio • 1 Bedroom
      assisted living, memory care

      Sunrise at East 56th

      139 E 56th St, New York, NY, 10022
    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story senior living facility building at dusk with lights on inside. In the foreground, there is a landscaped area with a sign that reads 'Legend Personal Care Memory Care' and the number 425. The building has multiple windows and a sloped roof.
      $5,725 – $7,442+4.3 (30)
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom • Studio
      assisted living, memory care

      Legend at Silver Creek

      425 Lambs Gap Rd, Mechanicsburg, PA, 17050

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 4 facilities
    2. 34 facilities$4,495/mo
    3. 47 facilities$4,492/mo
    4. 3 facilities
    5. 2 facilities
    6. 44 facilities$4,892/mo
    7. 71 facilities$5,284/mo
    8. 59 facilities$5,504/mo
    9. 13 facilities$4,188/mo
    10. 6 facilities$3,725/mo
    11. 40 facilities$4,761/mo
    12. 3 facilities$4,837/mo
    © 2025 Mirador Living