Olsen Rest Home

    366 Gibbs Pond Rd, Nesconset, NY, 11767
    4.3 · 18 reviews
    • Assisted living
    • Skilled nursing
    AnonymousLoved one of resident
    4.0

    Homey caring staff, small rooms

    I placed my grandmother here and, overall, I'm grateful-it's a small, family-run, homey place on a beautiful wooded lot with attentive, caring staff, very clean rooms, and a peaceful atmosphere; my mom was happier and looked years younger. Downsides: rooms are small, activities few, and I did notice occasional staff lapses and concerns around medication/reprimands. Admission was simple, management responsive, residents treated with dignity, and I would recommend it.

    Pricing

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    4.28 · 18 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      4.3
    • Staff

      4.2
    • Meals

      4.5
    • Amenities

      3.0
    • Value

      4.0

    Pros

    • Homey, comfortable family environment
    • Small, intimate facility (~20 residents)
    • Family-owned and operated since the 1950s
    • Caring, attentive and dedicated staff
    • Staff frequently go above and beyond
    • Outstanding management of medication (reported by some)
    • Residents described as cared for, safe, respectful and dignified
    • Impeccably clean facility
    • Well-groomed residents
    • Simple, straightforward admission process
    • Reasonably priced
    • Owner actively involved and responsive
    • Close to family/home
    • Good one-on-one care
    • Peaceful, tranquil setting on a beautiful wooded lot
    • Food enjoyed by residents
    • Friendly, helpful staff and case manager
    • Not overcrowded; small community feel
    • Comfy common areas and chairs
    • Many reviewers would recommend the facility

    Cons

    • Reports of overmedication/appearing 'stoned' during visits
    • Occasional reprimanding or poor interactions by staff
    • Some reviewers noted little attention from staff
    • Perceived variability in staff quality (some described as lacksadaisical)
    • Old rooms and worn furniture
    • Small activity space and limited activities offered
    • Some residents perceived as 'too old' for activities or less active
    • Small dining area and small rooms
    • Short-stay safety incident / staffing insufficiency reported after a fall
    • No kitchen in some 1-bedroom rooms
    • Facility described as old-fashioned or 'not pretty' by some
    • Inconsistency in experiences between reviewers

    Summary review

    Overall sentiment across the review summaries is largely positive, centered on Olsen Rest Home’s small, family-run, home-like atmosphere and a generally high level of personal attention. Many reviewers emphasize the intimate scale (about 20 residents), the family ownership since the 1950s, and the strong, caring relationships between staff and residents. Recurrent positive themes include cleanliness (several reviews call the home 'impeccably clean'), well-groomed residents, and staff who listen to concerns and often go above and beyond. The facility’s location on a wooded lot and its peaceful, homey ambience are frequently praised, as are practical positives such as a simple admission process, reasonable pricing, and the owner’s active involvement in operations. Multiple families explicitly state they would recommend the facility and report noticeable improvements in residents’ mood and appearance after moving in.

    Care quality and staff: The dominant narrative is that staff are kind, attentive, and provide respectful, dignified care. Comments such as 'staff are caring and attentive,' 'dedicated staff,' and 'staff phenomenal' appear repeatedly. Several reviewers note one-on-one attention and individualized care, and there are positive remarks about medication management being well handled in at least some cases. The case manager and owner are singled out as responsive and accessible. However, there is a notable minority of contrasting reports describing inconsistent staff performance — instances of perceived inattentiveness, reprimanding of residents, and characterization of some staff as lacksadaisical. An important, specific concern raised by some reviewers is overmedication: a few accounts describe residents appearing 'stoned' during visits, which conflicts with other reports praising medication management. This suggests variability in experiences that families should probe directly.

    Facilities and environment: The home-like, small-scale layout is a consistently positive factor, contributing to a family-like atmosphere and tranquility. The facility is described as well maintained overall, with many reviewers noting cleanliness and upkeep. At the same time, reviewers point out that the building and furnishings are older and not especially modern or 'pretty.' Rooms are described as small (one-bedroom units without kitchens were mentioned), and common areas like the dining room and activity room are limited in size. These physical constraints are linked to some complaints about cramped or basic accommodations and limited capacity for group activities.

    Activities and social life: Several reviewers appreciate that residents can be active and included in activities, and some families report their relative is happy and participates. Nonetheless, a clear pattern of concern is limited programming: multiple summaries mention few activities, a small activity room, and calls for more engagement opportunities. Some reviewers attribute limited activity involvement to residents being 'too old,' while others urge more structured or frequent activities. For prospective families prioritizing robust social programming and lively group activities, this is an area where Olsen Rest Home may not meet expectations without clarification on current activity schedules.

    Safety and incidents: Most reviews emphasize safety and attentive care, but there is at least one report of a short stay involving a fall and a subsequent safety concern tied to perceived staffing insufficiency. While not a widespread complaint in the summaries provided, this incident — together with the reports of inattentiveness and medication concerns — indicates potential variability in safety-related practices. Prospective families should inquire about staffing ratios, fall prevention protocols, and medication administration oversight to reconcile the generally positive safety impressions with the isolated negative accounts.

    Dining and practical considerations: Food is mentioned favorably by several reviewers, who said residents 'loved' the meals and appreciated friendly interactions during dining. Practical positives include easy admissions, reasonable pricing, proximity to family, and an owner who 'takes care of business.' On the other hand, the small dining area and the lack of a kitchen in certain one-bedroom rooms may be drawbacks for families expecting more apartment-like independence or larger communal dining experiences.

    Overall assessment and advice: The aggregate picture is of a small, affordable, family-owned home that provides warm, individualized care for many residents and families, with a strong culture of attentiveness and cleanliness. Yet there are recurring caveats: limited activity programming, small and older physical spaces, and isolated but concerning reports about medication effects and inconsistent staff behavior. These mixed signals suggest Olsen Rest Home will be a good fit for families seeking a close-knit, home-like environment and strong personal attention, but less well suited for those seeking modern facilities, extensive activities, or guaranteed consistency across all shifts.

    Recommendations for prospective families: Visit at multiple times of day to observe staff-resident interactions, check the activity schedule and availability of social programming, review medication administration and oversight procedures, ask about staffing ratios and fall-prevention measures, and inspect rooms and furnishings to confirm they meet expectations. Given the strongly positive reviews balanced with a few specific concerns, direct, specific questions during a tour will help determine whether Olsen Rest Home’s strengths align with a given resident’s needs.

    Location

    Map showing location of Olsen Rest Home

    About Olsen Rest Home

    Olsen Rest Home stays open all day and night, every day of the week, and folks there aim to make life easy and safe for seniors and their families, so right when you walk in, you'll notice they've set things up to feel welcoming with comfortable indoor common areas where residents can gather, relax, or enjoy quiet time whenever they want. The staff provide meals so residents don't have to worry about cooking, and they offer dining services and laundry, which takes another load off everyone's mind. You'll find regular activities to keep seniors engaged, from fun games and social events to structured educational and entertainment programs, and they offer both onsite and offsite devotional services for those who want them, so people can keep their routines and beliefs close while living there. Full personal care assistance is available, and staff handle more complex needs like diabetic management, incontinence care, and help for folks who can't walk easily, doing so in a way that encourages as much independence as possible but still giving gentle help when it's needed. Families get access to useful information and resources, which helps make the experience feel a little bit more steady during changes, and the place tries hard to foster a nurturing atmosphere so everyone-residents, visitors, and staff-feels genuinely supported day in and day out. There's a photo gallery you can look at to get a sense of life at the home, and the facility's built to make sure people can keep their dignity, feel safe, and find joy in everyday routines. Amenities are aimed at comfort and wellbeing, and everything's designed with residents and their loved ones in mind, though you won't find every detail spelled out, it's clear they focus on practical, quality care for those who need a bit more support as they age.

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    79 facilities$5,371/mo
    82 facilities$5,426/mo
    67 facilities$5,382/mo
    70 facilities$5,513/mo
    73 facilities$5,485/mo
    63 facilities$5,467/mo
    63 facilities$5,467/mo
    76 facilities$5,275/mo
    63 facilities$5,349/mo
    63 facilities$5,361/mo
    65 facilities$5,513/mo
    57 facilities$5,429/mo
    © 2025 Mirador Living