Premier Assisted Living

    319 Eldridge Ave, Orange Park, FL, 32073
    4.4 · 19 reviews
    • Assisted living
    AnonymousLoved one of resident
    4.0

    Warm staff, beautiful community, caveats

    I toured and moved my loved one here and overall I'm pleased: the staff are warm, responsive and genuinely caring, the community is clean, beautifully decorated and feels home-like/resort-like, meals are delicious, activities are plentiful, and security/medical support is solid. Downsides: it's not suited for care beyond level-2, evenings/weekends can be short-staffed with spotty communication, rooms open onto covered walkways (unpleasant in bad weather), and leadership/communication have had occasional hiccups. Good value for many - I recommend it with those caveats.

    Pricing

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    4.42 · 19 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      4.5
    • Staff

      4.7
    • Meals

      4.4
    • Amenities

      4.8
    • Value

      3.3

    Pros

    • Friendly, genuine and caring staff
    • Professional and responsive team
    • Staff frequently described as going above-and-beyond
    • Impressive, recently renovated amenities
    • Strong security and sense of safety
    • On-site medical staff and attentive care for medical conditions
    • Engaging daily activities and social programming
    • Home-like, resort-like atmosphere (not like a nursing home)
    • Delicious meals and varied menu options
    • Spacious, large resident rooms and bathrooms
    • Clean and well-maintained facility
    • Pet-friendly with pet therapy options
    • Active, sociable community with many visitors
    • Central, convenient location
    • Good value / affordable relative to other options
    • Helpful, informative tour staff and move-in support (specific praise for 'Jessica')
    • Library and recreational offerings (e.g., bingo)
    • Safe and secure environment noted repeatedly
    • Positive move-in experiences and individualized accommodations

    Cons

    • Weekend and evening staffing shortages
    • Difficulty reaching staff during evenings and weekends
    • Concerns about cost-cutting or doing things on the cheap
    • Not suitable for residents requiring higher levels of care (beyond level 2)
    • An advocate may be needed to ensure resident concerns are addressed
    • New administration cited for poor communication and lack of leadership continuity
    • Resident concerns sometimes go unanswered or unaddressed
    • Layout/room design described as motel-like and strange
    • Rooms that exit onto covered walkways expose residents to weather (rainy access requiring umbrella)
    • Lack of follow-up communication after move-in
    • Price or location not a fit for some families
    • Medicaid acceptance/decision uncertainty noted

    Summary review

    Overall sentiment across the reviews for Premier Assisted Living is predominantly positive, with repeated emphasis on high-quality staff, appealing amenities, strong social programming, and well-liked dining. Many reviewers highlight the staff as the community's strongest asset — described as friendly, genuine, professional, and often going "above-and-beyond." Specific staff members (notably a tour staff named Jessica) receive strong praise for being informative, patient, and responsive. The presence of on-site medical staff, attentive care for specific medical needs, and a generally calm, secure environment are frequently mentioned, contributing to an overall perception that residents are well cared for and comfortable.

    Facility and amenities are another consistent strength. Multiple reviewers note recently renovated, large resident rooms and bathrooms, a clean and well-maintained building, and amenities that create a resort-like or home-like atmosphere rather than a clinical nursing-home feel. Dining is a standout — many reviewers explicitly say their loved ones "love" the food, compliment menu variety and the dining room experience. The community is described as social and active, with engaging daily activities (bingo, library, organized events), pet-friendly programming including pet therapy, and a central location that fosters visits from family and friends.

    However, there are recurring operational and suitability concerns that prospective residents and families should weigh. Several reviewers report weekend and evening staffing shortages and difficulty reaching staff during off-hours. This operational gap appears to be one of the most frequently cited negatives and can affect timely responses to resident needs. Related to staffing and operations, a number of reviews express concern about recent administrative changes — incoming leadership received criticism for poor communication, lack of continuity, and not adequately addressing resident concerns. Some reviewers explicitly advise that an advocate may be necessary to ensure issues are heard and resolved.

    Physical layout and care-level limitations are other notable patterns. The community layout is described by some as unusual or "motel-like," with multiple comments about rooms that open onto covered walkways. Those walkways can be inconvenient or unpleasant in bad weather (reviewers mentioned needing an umbrella to reach the main building), which may be a practical downside for some residents. Several reviewers also caution that the facility is best suited for residents who require lower to moderate levels of assistance — specifically, it was characterized as not appropriate for individuals needing above-level-2 care. That limitation, combined with occasional operational shortfalls, suggests families should carefully confirm whether the facility's care scope matches their loved one's long-term needs.

    Value and fit show mixed but generally positive cues. Many reviewers call the community a good or affordable value compared to alternatives and note that it can be an excellent choice for residents with certain care needs. At the same time, a few families found the pricing or location not to be a good match for their situation, and at least one review mentioned Medicaid acceptance as pending or uncertain. There were also a few isolated mentions suggesting perceived cost-cutting in some areas — a point prospective residents may want to probe directly.

    In summary, Premier Assisted Living receives strong praise for its staff quality, pleasant and recently upgraded living spaces, excellent dining, robust social programming, and an atmosphere that feels more "home-like" than institutional. Those strengths are balanced by operational concerns around evening and weekend staffing, communication challenges tied to recent administrative turnover, layout/access issues for some rooms, and limits on higher-level clinical care. Prospective residents and families should consider visiting in person, asking targeted questions about weekend staffing and emergency response procedures, verifying care-level capabilities, confirming administrative stability and communication practices, and checking Medicaid/financial compatibility if applicable. When the care needs align with what the community provides and communication/staffing concerns are satisfactorily addressed, many reviewers recommend Premier as a comfortable, engaging, and good-value assisted living option.

    Location

    Map showing location of Premier Assisted Living

    About Premier Assisted Living

    Premier Assisted Living is a licensed assisted living facility in Orange Park, FL, with 100 beds, and it sits on Eldridge Avenue, not far off the main road, and it's a place where seniors can get long-term care that usually costs less than nursing home care, which can bring some peace of mind to families looking for help. The facility uses the term "Premier Assisted Living" to show their focus on supporting older residents who need care with daily activities like bathing, dressing, meal preparation, and medication management, and they've got a team that handles housekeeping, laundry, and planning social activities, so people can relax and focus on enjoying their days. They've got both private and semi-private apartments, available as suites or studios, and the rooms can be furnished or left unfinished for personal touches, and inside each room, there's high-speed internet, basic cable, and a Wi-Fi emergency call system to help keep people comfortable and safe. The place has 24-hour onsite security and maintenance, and there's always someone around for peace of mind.

    Residents can enjoy three chef-prepared meals a day, with menus made to meet different diets and tastes, and there's room service available for those days when someone'd rather eat in. Social and recreational activities are always in the schedule, from pet therapy and a putting green to an on-site library, theater room, and a wellness center, and there's a beauty and barber shop named Astoria House of Beauty, specifically set up for personal grooming needs. The facility is committed to supporting independence, privacy, dignity, and respect, so people who want to get around more on their own can, and those who need more help get it, with every resident able to move between care levels as their needs change over time. Transportation services, including a chauffeured limo, help folks get to medical appointments, shopping, or local events, and there's educational programming as well as group events in the shared dining facilities.

    Medication help is available, and professional staff is trained to assist with all the common care needs, including help with personal care, managing medicines, and even organizing the little things that come up during the day. The outdoor areas are made for relaxing in the sun or shade, and they've really tried to keep the place feeling home-like, without being stuffy or too formal, aiming for a healthy, resort-style lifestyle with as many options as possible-so you see a putting green but also quiet spots to read in the library, or spaces to gather for a movie at the theater. Residents can choose how much independence they want in their private apartments, and services change as their needs change. Premier Assisted Living is a fair housing and equal opportunity provider, with a broad range of care available for elderly residents in a secure, well-maintained building, staffed by a team that's reliable and compassionate, and the management and staff are experienced in handling the special needs that come with senior living, all with the aim of helping people age in place with as much comfort and dignity as possible.

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    • Aerial view of HearthStone at Leesburg senior living facility showing a large, single-story building with multiple wings, surrounded by landscaped gardens, parking lots with cars, and a road on one side. The building has a gray roof and beige walls, with green trees and bushes around the property.
      $2,580 – $4,390+4.4 (64)
      Semi-private
      assisted living, memory care

      HearthStone at Leesburg

      1309 Marlene St, Leesburg, FL, 34748
    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story senior living facility building under a clear blue sky with an American flag on a flagpole in front and a well-maintained grassy lawn surrounding the building.
      $4,350 – $5,655+4.4 (165)
      Semi-private • Studio
      assisted living, memory care

      The Summit of Lakewood Ranch

      11705 Evening Walk Dr, Lakewood Ranch, FL, 34211
    • Exterior view of a modern multi-story senior living facility building at dusk with balconies, palm trees, and illuminated lights along the facade and entrance area.
      $5,500+4.5 (114)
      1 Bedroom
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Belmont Village Senior Living Fort Lauderdale

      1031 Seminole Dr, Fort Lauderdale, FL, 33304
    • Exterior view of Renaissance on Peachtree, a multi-story building with large windows and a covered entrance. The building is surrounded by trees and greenery under a partly cloudy blue sky.
      $5,300+4.3 (118)
      2 Bedroom
      independent living, assisted living

      Renaissance on Peachtree

      3755 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA, 30319
    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story yellow and beige building with balconies and a green dome on top, illuminated at dusk with trees in the foreground and city buildings in the background.
      Pricing on request4.8 (214)
      suite
      independent living, assisted living

      The Palace at Coral Gables

      1 Andalusia Ave, Coral Gables, FL, 33134
    • Pedestrian-friendly street lined with multi-story residential buildings with ground-floor shops and palm trees under a blue sky.
      Pricing on request4.8 (154)
      suite
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Mirabelle

      7400 SW 88th St, Miami, FL, 33156

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 59 facilities$4,831/mo
    2. 60 facilities$4,712/mo
    3. 58 facilities$4,922/mo
    4. 35 facilities$4,124/mo
    5. 38 facilities$4,798/mo
    6. 22 facilities$4,874/mo
    7. 90 facilities$4,714/mo
    8. 32 facilities$4,159/mo
    9. 8 facilities$4,748/mo
    10. 4 facilities
    11. 8 facilities
    12. 14 facilities$4,873/mo
    © 2025 Mirador Living