Pricing ranges from
    $3,435 – 4,122/month

    Alabama Oaks Assisted Living

    1759 Alabama Dr, Winter Park, FL, 32789
    3.9 · 12 reviews
    • Assisted living
    • Memory care
    AnonymousLoved one of resident
    3.0

    Charming setting, inconsistent care oversight

    I had a mixed experience. The place has beautiful 1920s B&B charm, inviting porches, lovely grounds and many genuinely caring staff who gave excellent hands-on support and engaging activities for my dad. But management and oversight felt inconsistent - I saw staff on phones, A/Cs removed without family consent, mixed laundry, shared bathrooms/thresholds that are risky for mobility-challenged residents, thin menus, and even reports of abuse and screaming that had to be reported. If you value a homier atmosphere and attentive caregivers, it can be wonderful; if you need reliable management, privacy, or strong mobility support, be cautious.

    Pricing

    $3,435+/moSemi-privateAssisted Living
    $4,122+/mo1 BedroomAssisted Living

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    Healthcare services

    • Activities of daily living assistance
    • Assistance with bathing
    • Assistance with dressing
    • Assistance with transfers
    • Coordination with health care providers
    • Medication management

    Healthcare staffing

    • 24-hour supervision

    Meals and dining

    • Diabetes diet
    • Meal preparation and service
    • Special dietary restrictions

    Room

    • Cable
    • Fully furnished
    • Housekeeping and linen services
    • Telephone
    • Wifi

    Transportation

    • Transportation arrangement (medical)
    • Transportation to doctors appointments

    Community services

    • Move-in coordination

    Activities

    • Community-sponsored activities
    • Scheduled daily activities

    3.92 · 12 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      3.6
    • Staff

      3.7
    • Meals

      2.0
    • Amenities

      3.7
    • Value

      5.0

    Pros

    • bed-and-breakfast 1920s charm and homier atmosphere
    • inviting front porches and attractive grounds
    • beautiful facility and neighborhood setting
    • caring, compassionate, and understanding staff (reported by multiple reviewers)
    • RN-run owner/clinical leadership
    • reported high caregiver-to-resident ratio
    • nice dining room and onsite kitchen (positive for some reviewers)
    • stimulating activities and entertainment (mentioned positively by some)
    • amazing value and highly recommended by some families
    • staff described as good hands for residents and supportive

    Cons

    • inadequate room air conditioning and removal of window units without family consultation
    • staff not mingling with residents and frequently on cell phones
    • minimal oversight and poor management reported by multiple reviewers
    • inconsistent menus and meal service; reports of daily soup-and-sandwich lunches
    • not suitable for mobility-challenged residents due to thresholds and fall risk
    • shared bathrooms and few private bathrooms
    • residents clothes mixed with staff laundry
    • allegations of abuse, neglect, and significant distress (screaming, tears)
    • facility reportedly used as a landing pad for management's children
    • some reviewers describe activities as inadequate or a joke
    • polarized experiences with inconsistent quality of care across residents

    Summary review

    Overall sentiment in these reviews is strongly polarized, with a substantial number of highly positive comments praising the facility's homelike, bed-and-breakfast character and another substantial set of reviews describing serious care, safety, and management concerns. Several reviewers emphasize the facility's physical charm, 1920s character, inviting front porches, and attractive neighborhood and grounds. Those positive reviewers often pair the aesthetic praise with reports of compassionate, attentive staff, an RN-run ownership structure, a reportedly favorable caregiver-to-resident ratio, and engaging activities and dining for some residents. These reviewers describe quality-of-life emphasis, stimulating entertainment, and a supportive environment, calling the facility highly recommended and an amazing value in some cases.

    Conversely, multiple reviewers raised serious negative issues that cannot be overlooked. Common operational and care concerns include inadequate room air conditioning and at least one report that a window A/C unit was removed without consulting family. Several reviewers describe staff behavior problems such as employees spending time on cell phones, not interacting appropriately with residents, and minimal oversight by management. There are repeated allegations of poor management practices, including the claim that the facility has been used as a landing pad for managers' children and that residents sometimes have no visitors or voice in their care. Laundry and personal-care issues were also reported, notably residents' clothes being mixed with staff laundry.

    Safety and accessibility are recurring themes. The facility is an older converted home, which contributes to its charm but also creates practical hazards: thresholds and narrow transitions that present fall risk and make the home less appropriate for mobility-challenged residents. Shared bathrooms and a scarcity of private bathrooms were specifically mentioned, increasing concerns for privacy and individualized care. Dining reports are mixed: some reviewers praise the dining room and kitchen and the emphasis on quality of life, while others describe very limited, repetitive meals such as daily soup-and-sandwich lunches and inconsistencies between what families expect and what the kitchen provides.

    Allegations of abuse and neglect appear in the reviews and are among the most serious concerns. Words like abuse, disgusting care, screaming, and tears indicate that at least some reviewers experienced or observed severe mistreatment or distressing incidents, and one reviewer said they reported the facility to authorities. These allegations sit in stark contrast to other reviewers who described genuine, unmatched levels of caregiver attentiveness. The presence of such divergent experiences suggests inconsistent performance across staff shifts, wings, or time periods and highlights a need for careful verification.

    Activities and social programming are another area of mixed feedback. Some reviewers called activities a joke and criticized the lack of meaningful engagement, while others reported stimulating activities, social distancing during events, and good entertainment. This again points to inconsistency in programming or variability in how different residents experience the schedule.

    In summary, the reviews paint a picture of a facility with strong positives and troubling negatives. The property itself and some staff receive high praise for creating a warm, home-like environment with attentive care, clinical leadership under an RN owner, and good value for some families. At the same time, multiple reports raise red flags about environmental safety for mobility-impaired residents, inconsistent meal quality, questionable laundry practices, staff professionalism, and very serious allegations of abuse and neglect. The overall pattern is one of uneven quality: excellent experiences for some residents and deeply concerning experiences for others.

    For families considering this facility, recommended next steps based on the review themes are: schedule multiple in-person visits at different times and days to observe staff-resident interactions; tour rooms and bathrooms to assess thresholds, fall risk, and availability of private baths; ask directly about air conditioning policy, laundry processes, staffing ratios, and management oversight; request copies of menus and observe a mealtime; ask for activity calendars and observe an activity; check complaint and inspection histories with state licensing authorities; and speak to current families and staff about continuity of care and any past incidents. Given the severity of some allegations, it would also be reasonable to verify whether any complaints were filed and how they were addressed by management and regulators before making a placement decision.

    Location

    Map showing location of Alabama Oaks Assisted Living

    About Alabama Oaks Assisted Living

    Alabama Oaks Assisted Living sits in a quiet part of Winter Park, Florida, close to the historic Alabama Hotel, and for over 30 years it's been looking after seniors in this old neighborhood, with a name that goes back to the Alabama Hotel just down the block and a big oak tree by the building. The facility has 19 beds, making it the biggest of the Winter Park Elderly Services, LLC group, and it's licensed by the state of Florida with license number 37. The staff has decades of experience caring for older folks, with the administrator Jennifer Brown being a Registered Nurse, and the owners are Brooke Rose and Winter Park Elderly Services, LLC. The place feels like a Southern Bed & Breakfast, with home-like touches-leather couches, patterned curtains, big windows for natural light, and rooms with mature furnishings and art. There's a main kitchen and dining area with bar seating, dark wood cabinets, and modern lights, and common rooms have plush recliners, stylish decor, and calming spaces for relaxing or reading in the library or playing games. Bedrooms come in one or two-bedroom layouts, all wheelchair accessible, with features like private bathrooms, cable or satellite TV, and some unfurnished options. The whole building is wheelchair accessible.

    Care here centers on assisted living, with help for daily needs like bathing, dressing, toileting, walking, and moving from bed to chair, as well as medication management. The staff provides non-ambulatory care, diabetic care, incontinence care, and support for those with memory problems, including dementia care. There's help with transfers, 24-hour supervision, and staff on site at all times. The facility tailors care to each person, keeping dignity and independence in mind, and there's a close, family-like atmosphere since the setting is more intimate than larger places. Private apartments connect to shared dining and social areas. If someone needs a break, there's a respite program too.

    Meals are prepared on site with three types of service, and they offer vegetarian, low sodium, gluten free, and no sugar options, plus room service and guest meals. Housekeeping and laundry are part of regular care. Residents can get rides for errands, appointments, or outings, and the facility has a barber, beauty services, a lounge, and a game room. Religious services take place, and there's steady communication with physicians for health needs. The community earned a score of 7.3 on the Seniorly rating system, and the website offers more details for anyone interested. Alabama Oaks Assisted Living doesn't aim to be fancy, but it does offer reliable, supportive care in a home-like place with a long history in Winter Park.

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    • Aerial view of HearthStone at Leesburg senior living facility showing a large, single-story building with multiple wings, surrounded by landscaped gardens, parking lots with cars, and a road on one side. The building has a gray roof and beige walls, with green trees and bushes around the property.
      $2,580 – $4,390+4.4 (64)
      Semi-private
      assisted living, memory care

      HearthStone at Leesburg

      1309 Marlene St, Leesburg, FL, 34748
    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story senior living facility building under a clear blue sky with an American flag on a flagpole in front and a well-maintained grassy lawn surrounding the building.
      $4,350 – $5,655+4.4 (165)
      Semi-private • Studio
      assisted living, memory care

      The Summit of Lakewood Ranch

      11705 Evening Walk Dr, Lakewood Ranch, FL, 34211
    • Exterior view of a modern multi-story senior living facility building at dusk with balconies, palm trees, and illuminated lights along the facade and entrance area.
      $5,500+4.5 (114)
      1 Bedroom
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Belmont Village Senior Living Fort Lauderdale

      1031 Seminole Dr, Fort Lauderdale, FL, 33304
    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story yellow and beige building with balconies and a green dome on top, illuminated at dusk with trees in the foreground and city buildings in the background.
      Pricing on request4.8 (214)
      suite
      independent living, assisted living

      The Palace at Coral Gables

      1 Andalusia Ave, Coral Gables, FL, 33134
    • Pedestrian-friendly street lined with multi-story residential buildings with ground-floor shops and palm trees under a blue sky.
      Pricing on request4.8 (154)
      suite
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Mirabelle

      7400 SW 88th St, Miami, FL, 33156
    • Exterior view of Renaissance on Peachtree, a multi-story building with large windows and a covered entrance. The building is surrounded by trees and greenery under a partly cloudy blue sky.
      $5,300+4.3 (118)
      2 Bedroom
      independent living, assisted living

      Renaissance on Peachtree

      3755 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA, 30319

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 175 facilities$4,490/mo
    2. 153 facilities$4,578/mo
    3. 157 facilities$4,524/mo
    4. 186 facilities$4,393/mo
    5. 177 facilities$4,288/mo
    6. 142 facilities$4,664/mo
    7. 131 facilities$4,584/mo
    8. 131 facilities$4,340/mo
    9. 130 facilities$4,237/mo
    10. 110 facilities$4,858/mo
    11. 85 facilities$4,794/mo
    12. 102 facilities$4,639/mo
    © 2025 Mirador Living