The Plymouth

    1550 Gay Road, Winter Park, FL, 32789
    3.3 · 3 reviews
    • Independent living
    AnonymousCurrent/former resident
    3.0

    Clean, affordable facility, dishonest follow-up

    I liked the facility - very clean, affordable, excellent management and a great location; I would have given five stars for that. But after a sympathetic initial call (they promised to send an application and someone even claimed to be the manager) there was no follow-up, and I now suspect dishonest outreach/corruption.

    Pricing

    Schedule a Tour

    Amenities

    3.33 · 3 reviews

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      3.3
    • Staff

      3.0
    • Meals

      3.3
    • Amenities

      3.3
    • Value

      5.0

    Pros

    • Affordable cost
    • Good location
    • Very clean facilities
    • Excellent management (reported by some reviewers)
    • Sympathetic initial response from staff
    • High overall satisfaction (five-star review reported)
    • Some reviewers reported no complaints

    Cons

    • Poor follow-up / no contact after promises
    • Promised application not sent
    • Misrepresentation of staff identity (claimed to be manager but was not)
    • Allegations of corruption or dishonest outreach
    • Inconsistent communication and reliability

    Summary review

    The reviews for The Plymouth present a mixed but clear pattern of strong facility-level positives alongside notable and potentially serious communication and trust issues. On the positive side, reviewers consistently call out affordability, a good location, and cleanliness. One reviewer gave an overall five-star rating, explicitly stating there were no complaints and praising management as "excellent." Multiple comments describe an initially sympathetic or welcoming response from staff, which supports impressions of good front-line courtesy and an environment that some residents or visitors find satisfactory and well-run.

    However, a contrasting theme appears around follow-through and honesty in outreach. Several reviewers reported that staff promised to send an application but never followed up, leaving prospective residents or family members without the requested next steps. One review specifically notes someone claiming to be the manager who, in fact, was not, which raises concerns about transparency of staff roles. There is also an explicit allegation of corruption or dishonest outreach in the summaries provided. Taken together, these points suggest inconsistent administrative processes and potential problems with accountability and trustworthiness in communications.

    The juxtaposition of "excellent management" and "very clean" against accusations of misrepresentation and poor follow-up indicates that experiences at The Plymouth may vary significantly depending on the individual staff members involved or the timing/context of interactions. Facility-related aspects that reviewers commented on (cleanliness, cost, location) are uniformly positive, while process-related aspects (application handling, information delivery, truthfulness of representatives) are the main recurring negatives. The strong positive comments suggest that when operations run smoothly, residents or visitors can be very satisfied; the negative comments suggest that the facility’s systems for onboarding and external communication may be fragile or inconsistently enforced.

    Notably, reviewers did not provide information about clinical care quality, dining, activities, or daily care specifics in these summaries. That absence means the available feedback is weighted toward administrative and front-desk experiences and general impressions of the facility environment. The most significant pattern to draw from these reviews is that The Plymouth appears to be an affordable, well-located, and clean facility with potential for strong management — yet there are credible reports of lapses in communication, broken promises, and at least one allegation of dishonest outreach. Prospective residents and families should weigh the positive environment and value against the risk of inconsistent follow-up and verify communication and staff credentials before committing.

    Location

    Map showing location of The Plymouth

    About The Plymouth

    The Plymouth sits in Winter Park and has studio and one-bedroom apartments for seniors aged 62 and up, and these apartments come either furnished or unfurnished with private bathrooms, kitchenettes, and walk-in closets, and there are also efficiency units with baths and dressing closets. The six-story building stands in a park-like setting and has shaded seating, outdoor recreation areas, and shuffleboard, so residents can enjoy both indoor and outdoor spaces. The Plymouth is pet-friendly, allowing both cats and dogs with some weight limits for dogs. The building uses a tele-entry system for security, and there are safety and accessibility features in all apartments, plus a state-of-the-art fire sprinkler system and elevators. The community provides regular monthly events, social activities, and recreational options, including a community room with televisions and meeting tables, a library with books and magazines for leisure and quiet study, and computer stations with free internet.

    Residents have access to a community pantry twice a month with healthy food choices, and there's a free Seniors First Lunch program served twice weekly. Laundry rooms, trash chutes on every floor, cable and phone hookups, granite countertops, indoor entryways from air-conditioned hallways, and spacious walk-in closets are included in the amenities, and electricity, water, sewer, and trash services are covered in the rent. There's transportation and parking, with transportation available at an extra cost. Staff at The Plymouth are trained, friendly, and always accessible, providing support, answering questions, and offering programs that help residents keep a good quality of life. Residents who need help with daily tasks can access assisted living services, which cover bathing, dressing, laundry, cooking, bathroom use, medication management, and more. The Plymouth has a memory care program with 24-hour supervision for those with Alzheimer's disease, dementia, or other conditions that need attention, with special features to reduce wandering and confusion.

    The Plymouth also provides adult day care, nursing and rehab, home health care, and independent living options for seniors who want hassle-free living in a social setting. For those looking for short-term or long-term stays, the community supports both, and companion aides are available for non-medical help. The building sits close to shopping, parks, restaurants, and golf courses, making outings possible. Maintenance staff stays on-site and are available 24 hours a day for emergencies. The Plymouth belongs to a property management company that manages similar senior communities. Residents can expect a straightforward, thoughtful environment that helps them stay active and comfortable as they age.

    People often ask...

    Nearby Communities

    • Aerial view of HearthStone at Leesburg senior living facility showing a large, single-story building with multiple wings, surrounded by landscaped gardens, parking lots with cars, and a road on one side. The building has a gray roof and beige walls, with green trees and bushes around the property.
      $2,580 – $4,390+4.4 (64)
      Semi-private
      assisted living, memory care

      HearthStone at Leesburg

      1309 Marlene St, Leesburg, FL, 34748
    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story senior living facility building under a clear blue sky with an American flag on a flagpole in front and a well-maintained grassy lawn surrounding the building.
      $4,350 – $5,655+4.4 (165)
      Semi-private • Studio
      assisted living, memory care

      The Summit of Lakewood Ranch

      11705 Evening Walk Dr, Lakewood Ranch, FL, 34211
    • Exterior view of a modern multi-story senior living facility building at dusk with balconies, palm trees, and illuminated lights along the facade and entrance area.
      $5,500+4.5 (114)
      1 Bedroom
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Belmont Village Senior Living Fort Lauderdale

      1031 Seminole Dr, Fort Lauderdale, FL, 33304
    • Exterior view of a large, multi-story yellow and beige building with balconies and a green dome on top, illuminated at dusk with trees in the foreground and city buildings in the background.
      Pricing on request4.8 (214)
      suite
      independent living, assisted living

      The Palace at Coral Gables

      1 Andalusia Ave, Coral Gables, FL, 33134
    • Pedestrian-friendly street lined with multi-story residential buildings with ground-floor shops and palm trees under a blue sky.
      Pricing on request4.8 (154)
      suite
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Mirabelle

      7400 SW 88th St, Miami, FL, 33156
    • Exterior view of Renaissance on Peachtree, a multi-story building with large windows and a covered entrance. The building is surrounded by trees and greenery under a partly cloudy blue sky.
      $5,300+4.3 (118)
      2 Bedroom
      independent living, assisted living

      Renaissance on Peachtree

      3755 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA, 30319

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    186 facilities$4,799/mo
    177 facilities$4,743/mo
    175 facilities$5,032/mo
    153 facilities$4,639/mo
    131 facilities$5,076/mo
    130 facilities$4,465/mo
    142 facilities$4,840/mo
    157 facilities$4,573/mo
    131 facilities$5,185/mo
    112 facilities$4,592/mo
    110 facilities$5,330/mo
    85 facilities$3,724/mo
    © 2025 Mirador Living