The Manors at the Colony Preserve

    49 Cricket Ct, Shirley, NY 11967
    • Independent Living
    • Assisted Living
    4.0ยท25 reviews

    Quiet friendly 55+ gated community

    I visited with my parents and purchased a unit in this beautiful, quiet 55+ gated community - the condos and lawns are well kept, residents and staff are friendly, and the huge clubhouse with plenty of equipment and great amenities has me optimistic as we await phase 2.

    Loved one of resident
    Jul 2026

    Schedule a Tour

    Date of Tour
    Time Window
    Tour Type

    You selected in-person tour on in the

    Reviews

    4.04ยท(25)

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      4.0
    • Staff

      2.5
    • Meals

      4.0
    • Amenities

      3.8
    • Value

      4.0

    Pros

    • Gated, private location
    • Quiet, scenic grounds
    • Large clubhouse with extensive fitness equipment
    • Well-maintained lawns and landscaping
    • Friendly, welcoming staff
    • Sociable resident community
    • Variety of condo floor plans and models
    • New-construction units with modern finishes
    • Over-55-focused amenities
    • Onsite recreational facilities

    Cons

    • Unreliable construction completion timelines
    • Sales-contract and timeline transparency issues
    • Insufficient relocation and cost-mitigation support
    • Ongoing construction-related disruption
    • Poor roadway and entry maintenance
    • Inconsistent communication from management

    Summary of reviews

    The Manors at the Colony Preserve presents as an attractive, purpose-built over-55 condo community with a strong emphasis on privacy and onsite amenities. Reviewers consistently note a gated, secluded setting with well-kept lawns and a large clubhouse that houses substantial fitness and recreational equipment. The buildings and units are described as new and modern; several visitors and purchasers cited multiple floor-plan options and generally positive impressions of the residences themselves.

    Social life and staff interactions are described positively. The community atmosphere is characterized as quiet, peaceful, and welcoming; reviewers mention friendly residents and cordial staff interactions. The clubhouse and onsite recreational facilities appear to be focal points for activity and socializing, which supports an active lifestyle for many residents. There is limited information about clinical care or formal assisted-living services in the available reviews, which is consistent with the property operating primarily as a condominium community tailored to active adults.

    A repeated operational concern involves the development and management of the project. Multiple accounts describe significant delays in construction and occupancy timelines, which have created logistical and financial strain for buyers who planned relocations around promised delivery dates. Relatedly, reviewers raised issues with sales and contract transparency, including unclear or shifting move-in schedules and limited support for extra storage or temporary housing costs incurred while waiting to occupy units. Ongoing phases of development also contribute to disruption for residents and visitors.

    Physical-maintenance issues were mentioned primarily in exterior infrastructure: the entry roadway and immediate access points were described as in need of improvement, which affects first impressions and day-to-day access. Communication from management about schedules, roadwork, and completion dates was identified as inconsistent; prospective buyers are advised to seek written timeline commitments and to clarify contingency plans for construction delays.

    For prospective residents and families: the site offers strong lifestyle and amenity advantages for active older adults, including a substantial clubhouse and a pleasant, secure setting. Those considering purchase should investigate contract terms, ask for firm move-in schedules and contingency provisions, budget for potential interim housing or storage costs, and verify planned road and exterior maintenance timelines. Visiting the community during active construction phases and speaking with current residents can help clarify day-to-day conditions while build-out continues.

    Reviews written on Mirador

    We have no reviews to show about The Manors at the Colony Preserve.

    Help other families by writing a review about your experience with this community.

    Location

    Map showing location of The Manors at the Colony Preserve

    The Manors at the Colony Preserve is located at 49 Cricket Ct, Shirley, NY, 11967.

    About The Manors at the Colony Preserve

    The Manors at The Colony Preserve is a gated 55+ community situated in Shirley, New York, offering active adults a serene yet vibrant living environment. Designed with a focus on maintenance-free living, this community caters to those seeking both privacy and the opportunity to engage in a dynamic social atmosphere. Set amidst a backdrop of picturesque lakes and landscaped grounds, The Manors at The Colony Preserve is planned for 150 homes organized into elegant six-unit townhome buildings. The development began in 2013 and showcases three distinct single-level home layouts, ranging from 1,322 to 1,598 square feet. Each residence features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, and a one-car garage, with interiors boasting nine-foot ceilings, gourmet kitchens equipped with stainless steel appliances, and luxurious master suites with separate his and hers closets.

    Residents enjoy a lifestyle brimming with amenities and opportunities for enrichment. At the heart of the community lies a beautifully appointed clubhouse, where neighbors come together in a welcoming environment that fosters new friendships and lifelong connections. The clubhouse contains a multi-purpose room for gatherings and events, a catering kitchen for special occasions, and a dedicated game room for leisure and entertainment. A modern fitness center is equipped with both cardiovascular and strength-training equipment, enabling residents to maintain healthy and active routines year-round.

    Outdoor amenities are thoughtfully designed to complement the communityโ€™s active living philosophy. Homeowners can take advantage of an inviting outdoor pool for relaxation during warm weather or participate in friendly matches on the bocce ball courts. For those who enjoy golf, there is a putting green perfect for practice and unwinding. A scenic gazebo and a tranquil lake offer peaceful spaces to enjoy nature and quiet reflection.

    The Manors at The Colony Preserve ensures a stress-free lifestyle by taking care of all exterior home maintenance, landscaping, and snow removal through a reasonable monthly association fee. This places more freedom and time in the hands of residents, allowing them to fully embrace the leisure and social activities available. Throughout the year, the community organizes a variety of events and clubs, from lively parties to card games and hobby groups, fostering a lively calendar of activities where residents are encouraged to exercise their bodies, expand their minds, and explore new interests.

    The location of The Manors at The Colony Preserve on Long Island means residents benefit from proximity to a wealth of dining, shopping, and recreational options. Nearby attractions include the Bellport-Brookhaven Historical Society, Grumman Memorial Park, Carmanโ€™s River Maritime Center, Brookhaven Volunteer Fire Museum, and Patchogue Theatre. Furthermore, the areaโ€™s natural beauty can be enjoyed through its famous beaches, rivers ideal for canoeing, scenic biking trails, and numerous parks perfect for picnics and gatherings.

    With its combination of low-maintenance homes, upscale amenities, and a close-knit, welcoming neighborhood, The Manors at The Colony Preserve stands out as a desirable option for active adults seeking an engaging and comfortable retirement lifestyle in Suffolk County, New York. The community offers residents the perfect blend of relaxation, recreation, and convenience, all within the secure setting of a gated enclave.

    People often ask...

    The Manors at the Colony Preserve offers independent living and assisted living.

    The full address for this community is 49 Cricket Ct, Shirley, NY 11967.

    No, The Manors at the Colony Preserve does not offer respite care. Respite care in assisted living communities provides temporary, short-term relief for primary caregivers by offering professional care for their loved ones. It allows individuals to stay in an assisted living community for a limited time, giving caregivers a break while ensuring residents receive necessary support and assistance with daily activities.

    Disclaimer

    Mirador Living is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of The Manors at the Colony Preserve. The information above has not been verified or approved by the owner or operator. For exact information, please contact The Manors at the Colony Preserve directly. There is no cost for this service. We are compensated by the community you select.

    Are you an owner or operator of this community?

    Claim this listing to receive messages from prospective customers and manage your community page.

    Nearby Communities

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 9 facilities
    2. 12 facilities$5,457/mo
    3. 9 facilities$5,457/mo
    4. 27 facilities$5,815/mo
    5. 6 facilities
    6. 19 facilities$5,885/mo
    7. 27 facilities$5,815/mo
    8. 24 facilities$5,684/mo
    9. 10 facilities$6,882/mo
    10. 40 facilities$5,869/mo
    11. 7 facilities$5,457/mo
    12. 42 facilities$5,733/mo
    ยฉ 2026 Mirador Living