Prices shown are estimates and subject to change. Contact your senior living advisor for current pricing.
Request a Tour
Amenities
Healthcare services
Activities of daily living assistance
Assistance with bathing
Assistance with dressing
Assistance with transfers
Medication management
Mental wellness program
Healthcare staffing
12-16 hour nursing
24-hour call system
24-hour supervision
Meals and dining
Diabetes diet
Meal preparation and service
Restaurant-style dining
Special dietary restrictions
Room
Air-conditioning
Cable
Fully furnished
Housekeeping and linen services
Kitchenettes
Private bathrooms
Telephone
Wifi
Memory care community services
Mild cognitive impairment
Specialized memory care programming
Transportation
Community operated transportation
Transportation arrangement
Transportation arrangement (non-medical)
Common areas
Beauty salon
Computer center
Dining room
Fitness room
Gaming room
Garden
Outdoor space
Small library
Wellness center
Community services
Concierge services
Fitness programs
Move-in coordination
Activities
Community-sponsored activities
Planned day trips
Resident-run activities
Scheduled daily activities
Reviews
3.78·(64)
Overall rating
5
4
3
2
1
Care
3.0
Staff
3.7
Meals
3.0
Amenities
2.4
Value
2.0
Pros
Compassionate, family-style caregiving
Attentive direct-care staff and helpful nurses
Supportive unit supervisors and engaged leadership
Helpful admissions and case-management support
Private rooms with private bathrooms
Solarium and rooms with lake views
Central downtown location near stores and services
On-site transportation to medical appointments
Varied activity program (movies, bingo, exercise, puzzles)
Dining room and breakfast-area meal options
Accepts Medicaid
Seven-day availability and accessible administrative contact
Quiet floors and calm living areas
Perceived reasonable value for location
Cons
Inconsistent staffing levels and floor coverage
Gaps in clinical oversight and RN availability
Incontinence-care delays and hygiene-management concerns
Sanitation and odor concerns in some areas
Maintenance and repair backlogs (furniture, plumbing, HVAC)
Inconsistent emergency-response timeliness
Gaps in wander-management and exit monitoring
Poor coordination and communication with families and external providers
Variable food quality and dining satisfaction
Admissions and bed-availability delays
Resident property-security concerns and allegations of theft
Inconsistent visitor and telephone-access protocols
Variable activity engagement for residents with higher support needs
Summary of reviews
Reviews of Mary Agnes Manor present a mixed picture with clear strengths alongside recurring operational concerns. Many families and residents praise the direct-care teams, describing compassionate, family-style caregiving, attentive aides and nurses, and strong unit supervisors. Admissions and case-management staff are often described as helpful, and several reviewers singled out individual leaders for responsive, seven-day availability. The facility's central downtown location, private rooms with private bathrooms, lakeside solarium and scenic views are commonly cited as positive attributes. Transportation to medical appointments and a varied activities program (movies, bingo, exercise classes and puzzles) are additional strengths that support resident quality of life.
Care quality and staffing are areas of divergence. Positive accounts emphasize individualized attention and staff who "go the extra mile," while contrasting accounts describe inconsistent staffing coverage, absenteeism on some shifts, and concerns about the availability of licensed nursing oversight. These patterns translate into service gaps for some families: delayed responses to clinical needs, concerns about hygiene-management and incontinence-care timeliness, and, in a few cases, lapses in supervision that raised safety worries. Prospective families should ask about current staffing ratios, RN coverage, and emergency-response protocols during their tour.
Dining and activities elicit mixed feedback. Several reviewers appreciate the dining room setup, breakfast options and the breadth of planned activities, and some describe food as excellent. Others describe inconsistent meal quality and limited social engagement for residents with higher support needs. Activity offerings appear adequate for many residents, but engagement and appropriateness for memory-impaired residents were described as variable.
Facility condition and maintenance are likewise inconsistent across reviews. Positive comments note clean, quiet floors and attractive views in some units. Conversely, other accounts describe maintenance issues such as broken furniture, plumbing problems, HVAC/temperature-control concerns, and sanitation or odor concerns in particular areas. These issues appear to be localized rather than uniform, but they point to variability in housekeeping and building upkeep across the campus.
Management and communication show a similar split. Several families praised accessible and responsive administrative staff, named leaders who provide strong support, and described clear coordination with families. At the same time, multiple reviews describe poor communication, unreturned calls, and coordination problems with outside providers. Admissions capacity and bed-availability delays were also reported as an administrative challenge. There are also serious operational concerns tied to resident property security and alleged loss of belongings; these allegations should be explored directly with management and during visits.
Notable patterns across the reviews are polarization by shift/unit and variability over time: the experience appears to depend strongly on which unit or shift a resident is on and which staff are present. For decision-making: visit multiple times (including evenings/weekends), request current staffing ratios and RN coverage, review sanitation and maintenance practices, ask about wander-management and exit monitoring, sample meals and review activity schedules, and inquire about property-security measures and complaint-resolution processes. These steps will help families balance the facility's clear strengths in personal caregiving and location against operational concerns that could affect safety and daily living.
Reviews written on Mirador
We have no reviews to show about Mary Agnes Manor.
Help other families by writing a review about your experience with this community.
Location
Mary Agnes Manor is located at 307 Porter Ave, Buffalo, NY, 14201.
About Mary Agnes Manor
Mary Agnes Manor is dedicated to providing individualized programs that support seniors as they navigate the challenges and joys of advancing age. Perfectly nestled on the beautiful and historic D’Youville University campus, this care home offers a harmonious setting that balances accessibility to urban amenities with the tranquility of an idyllic neighborhood. Residents here are treated to captivating views of both Lake Erie and Downtown Buffalo, creating an uplifting environment where nature and city life blend seamlessly.
The assisted living services at Mary Agnes Manor are thoughtfully designed to address a range of age-related needs. Each resident’s experience is customized through close collaboration among residents, their families, physicians, and community agencies. This careful planning ensures that personal preferences and unique health considerations are always at the forefront, allowing every resident to both live and thrive.
Daily life at Mary Agnes Manor is engaging and fulfilling. Residents enjoy a variety of programs and activities that encourage socialization, mental stimulation, and physical well-being. For those who wish to explore, the home’s exceptional location puts stores, parks, and local entertainment just a short walk away, promoting independence and community engagement. For those who prefer to stay in, a comprehensive schedule of activity programs ensures there’s always something fun to look forward to inside the manor itself.
The team at Mary Agnes Manor is committed to delivering a warm, supportive experience from the moment a resident moves in. Every aspect of the community—from its scenic surroundings to its dedicated staff—has been crafted to foster a sense of belonging, comfort, and ongoing opportunity for personal growth.
People often ask...
Mary Agnes Manor offers competitive pricing, with rates starting at a cost of $5,944 per month.
Mary Agnes Manor offers independent living, assisted living, memory care, and skilled nursing.
There are 21 photos of Mary Agnes Manor on Mirador.
Yes, Mary Agnes Manor allows residents to age in place and adjust their level of care as needed.
The full address for this community is 307 Porter Ave, Buffalo, NY 14201.
No, Mary Agnes Manor does not offer respite care.
Respite care in assisted living communities provides temporary, short-term relief for primary caregivers by offering professional care for their loved ones. It allows individuals to stay in an assisted living community for a limited time, giving caregivers a break while ensuring residents receive necessary support and assistance with daily activities.
Safety & Compliance
In New York, the State Department of Health licenses adult care facilities and assisted living programs, posting relicensure surveys, complaint investigations, and inspections.
Identified one violation of environmental standards.
487.11 (j) (1-3)Environmental standards
03 Dec 2025Complaint
03 Dec 2025Complaint
Identified three deficiencies related to resident protections, admission and retention standards, and resident services. Plan/notice of correction approved.
487.5 (a) (3) (xi)Resident protections
494.4 (a)Admission and retention standards
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
13 Nov 2025Complaint
13 Nov 2025Complaint
Investigated the complaint, found one violation, and approved a plan to correct.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
04 Nov 2025Complaint
04 Nov 2025Complaint
Identified three violations related to resident protections, admission and retention standards, and resident services.
487.5 (a) (3) (xi)Resident protections
494.4 (a)Admission and retention standards
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
22 Oct 2025Complaint
22 Oct 2025Complaint
Found 1 deficiency related to medication management.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
08 Oct 2025Complaint
08 Oct 2025Complaint
Found no deficiencies. No violations were cited during the complaint survey.
10 Sept 2025Complaint
10 Sept 2025Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
30 Jul 2025Complaint
30 Jul 2025Complaint
Investigated a complaint and identified deficiencies across multiple regulatory areas, including operating certificates, resident services, food service, personnel, environmental standards, disaster planning, admission and retention standards, and medication management.
485.5 (g)Operating certificates
487.7 (f) (8)Resident services
487.8 (e) (1)Food service
487.8 (e) (12-13)Food service
487.9 (a) (1)Personnel
487.9 (a) (6)Personnel
487.11 (f) (8)Environmental standards
487.11 (f) (12)Environmental standards
487.11 (f) (17)Environmental standards
487.11 (f) (19)Environmental standards
487.11 (i) (1)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (1-3)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (13)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (14)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (15)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (16)Environmental standards
487.12 (a-b)Disaster and emergency planning
1001.7 (k) (5)Admission and retention standards.
1001.10 (i) (1)Resident services.
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (4-7)Medication management
01 Jul 2025Complaint
01 Jul 2025Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
11 Jun 2025Complaint
11 Jun 2025Complaint
Identified 22 violations related to operating certificates, resident services, food service, personnel, environmental standards, disaster and emergency planning, admission and retention standards, and medication management.
485.5 (g)Operating certificates
487.7 (f) (8)Resident services
487.8 (e) (1)Food service
487.8 (e) (12-13)Food service
487.9 (a) (1)Personnel
487.9 (a) (6)Personnel
487.11 (f) (8)Environmental standards
487.11 (f) (12)Environmental standards
487.11 (f) (17)Environmental standards
487.11 (f) (19)Environmental standards
487.11 (i) (1)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (1-3)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (13)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (14)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (15)Environmental standards
487.11 (k) (16)Environmental standards
487.12 (a-b)Disaster and emergency planning
1001.7 (k) (5)Admission and retention standards.
1001.10 (i) (1)Resident services.
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (4-7)Medication management
23 May 2025Complaint
23 May 2025Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
22 May 2025Complaint
22 May 2025Complaint
Investigated a complaint survey and found no deficiencies.
23 Apr 2025Complaint
23 Apr 2025Complaint
Investigated a complaint survey and identified two violations. Approved a plan to address them.
485.5 (g)Operating certificates
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
25 Mar 2025Complaint
25 Mar 2025Complaint
Identified two violations related to operating certificates and resident services during a complaint survey.
485.5 (g)Operating certificates
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
11 Mar 2025Complaint
11 Mar 2025Complaint
Investigated a complaint and cited two deficiencies related to resident services and medication management.
487.7 (f) (11) (iii)Resident services
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
19 Feb 2025Complaint
19 Feb 2025Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
17 Feb 2025Complaint
17 Feb 2025Complaint
Identified four violations. The cited issues related to general provisions, resident services, and medication management.
487.3 (g) (1-2)General provisions
487.7 (f) (8)Resident services
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (4-7)Medication management
14 Feb 2025Complaint
14 Feb 2025Complaint
Identified deficiencies related to resident services and medication management.
487.7 (f) (11) (iii)Resident services
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
08 Jan 2025Complaint
08 Jan 2025Complaint
Found no deficiencies. No violations were cited.
07 Jan 2025Complaint
07 Jan 2025Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
31 Dec 2024Complaint
31 Dec 2024Complaint
Investigated the complaint and cited four violations; a plan to correct was approved. Violations involved general provisions, resident services, and medication management.
487.3 (g) (1-2)General provisions
487.7 (f) (8)Resident services
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (4-7)Medication management
30 Dec 2024Complaint
30 Dec 2024Complaint
Found no deficiencies. No violations were cited and no plan of correction was required.
14 Nov 2024Complaint
14 Nov 2024Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
25 Sept 2024Complaint
25 Sept 2024Complaint
Found no deficiencies. No violations were cited.
09 Sept 2024Complaint
09 Sept 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint survey and found no deficiencies.
27 Aug 2024Complaint
27 Aug 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint and identified a deficiency related to resident services.
487.7 (d) (1) (i)Resident services
26 Jul 2024Complaint
26 Jul 2024Complaint
Identified three deficiencies regarding admission standards and resident services; a plan to correct the issues was approved.
487.4 (a)Admission standards
487.4(f)-(g)Admission standards
487.7 (d) (11)Resident services
09 Jul 2024Complaint
09 Jul 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint survey and found two violations related to resident services and environmental standards.
487.7 (d) (11)Resident services
487.11 (a)Environmental standards
13 Jun 2024Complaint
13 Jun 2024Complaint
Found two deficiencies related to resident services and environmental standards.
487.7 (d) (11)Resident services
487.11 (a)Environmental standards
04 Jun 2024Complaint
04 Jun 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint and cited one deficiency related to medication management.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
01 May 2024Complaint
01 May 2024Complaint
Investigated a medication management violation and identified one deficiency.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
25 Mar 2024Complaint
25 Mar 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint and identified one deficiency related to medication management.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
15 Mar 2024Complaint
15 Mar 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint and identified four violations.
494.4 (k)Admission and retention standards
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (2)Medication management.
14 Mar 2024Complaint
14 Mar 2024Complaint
Cited two deficiencies and approved a plan of correction.
485.5 (f)Operating certificates
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
29 Feb 2024Complaint
29 Feb 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint and identified four violations.
494.4 (k)Admission and retention standards
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (2)Medication management.
26 Jan 2024Complaint
26 Jan 2024Complaint
Investigated a complaint, identified five deficiencies, and approved a plan/notice of correction.
487.4 (c) (5)Admission standards
487.7 (d) (6) (i)Resident services
487.7 (f) (5)Resident services
487.7 (f) (11) (iii)Resident services
1001.7 (k) (5)Admission and retention standards.
09 Jan 2024Complaint
09 Jan 2024Complaint
Identified three violations affecting resident services, personnel, and admission and retention standards.
487.7 (d) (6) (i)Resident services
487.9 (a) (3)Personnel
1001.7 (k) (1)Admission and retention standards.
15 Nov 2023Complaint
15 Nov 2023Complaint
Cited a deficiency in medication management and approved a plan of correction.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
28 Sept 2023Complaint
28 Sept 2023Complaint
Approved a plan of correction after identifying three violations related to resident services, personnel, and admission and retention standards.
487.7 (d) (6) (i)Resident services
487.9 (a) (3)Personnel
1001.7 (k) (1)Admission and retention standards.
20 Sept 2023Complaint
20 Sept 2023Complaint
Approved a plan of correction after identifying three violations.
487.7 (d) (10) (i-iii)Resident services
487.7 (d) (11)Resident services
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
07 Sept 2023Complaint
07 Sept 2023Complaint
Identified one deficiency concerning resident services and approved a plan of correction.
487.7 (d) (1) (i)Resident services
18 Aug 2023Complaint
18 Aug 2023Complaint
Identified three violations.
487.7 (d) (10) (i-iii)Resident services
487.7 (d) (11)Resident services
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
10 Aug 2023Complaint
10 Aug 2023Complaint
Found five violations and approved a plan of correction.
487.4 (c) (5)Admission standards
487.7 (d) (6) (i)Resident services
487.7 (f) (5)Resident services
487.7 (f) (11) (iii)Resident services
1001.7 (k) (5)Admission and retention standards.
07 Jul 2023Complaint
07 Jul 2023Complaint
Identified 21 deficiencies across operating certificates, resident services, food service, environmental standards, disaster planning, admission and retention standards, medication management, and personnel.
485.5 (f)Operating certificates
487.7 (d) (1) (iv)Resident services
487.7 (d) (6) (ii)Resident services
487.7 (d) (11)Resident services
487.7 (d) (12-13)Resident services
487.7 (f) (11) (i-v)Resident services
487.7 (f) (11) (iii)Resident services
487.7 (f) (12) (iii)Resident services
487.8 (c)Food service
487.11 (f) (8)Environmental standards
487.11 (f) (19)Environmental standards
487.11 (i) (7)Environmental standards
487.12 (a-b)Disaster and emergency planning
1001.7 (g)(1-3)Admission and retention standards.
1001.7 (h) (1)Admission and retention standards.
1001.7 (k) (1)Admission and retention standards.
1001.10 (i) (5-8)Resident services.
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (3)Medication management.
1001.10 (l) (4-7)Medication management
1001.11 (c) (2) (i-iv)Personnel.
06 Jun 2023Inspection
06 Jun 2023Inspection
Identified one deficiency and approved a plan of correction.
485.5 (f)Operating certificates
05 Jun 2023Inspection
05 Jun 2023Inspection
Found no deficiencies. No violations were cited.
11 May 2023Complaint
11 May 2023Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
08 May 2023Complaint
08 May 2023Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
23 Feb 2023Complaint
23 Feb 2023Complaint
Identified two violations and approved a plan of correction.
487.11 (k) (8)Environmental standards
1001.11 (c) (2) (i-iv)Personnel.
04 Nov 2022Inspection
04 Nov 2022Inspection
Found no deficiencies.
25 Oct 2022Complaint
25 Oct 2022Complaint
Identified three deficiencies related to resident services and medication management.
487.7 (f) (11) (i-v)Resident services
487.7 (f) (11) (iii)Resident services
1001.10 (l)(1)Medication management.
18 Oct 2022Inspection
18 Oct 2022Inspection
Cited one violation related to records and reports.
485.11 (b)Records and reports
29 Sept 2022Inspection
29 Sept 2022Inspection
Cited a records and reports deficiency and approved a plan of correction.
485.11 (b)Records and reports
11 Jul 2022Complaint
11 Jul 2022Complaint
Found no deficiencies.
08 Jun 2022Complaint
08 Jun 2022Complaint
Found no deficiencies during a complaint survey.
16 May 2022Inspection
16 May 2022Inspection
Identified a violation related to operating certificates.
485.5 (f)Operating certificates
09 Feb 2022Inspection
09 Feb 2022Inspection
Identified one deficiency.
487.10 (e) (2)Records and reports
01 Jul 2021Inspection
01 Jul 2021Inspection
Found no deficiencies.
Disclaimer
Mirador Living is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of Mary Agnes Manor. The information above has not been verified or approved by the owner or operator. For exact information, please contact Mary Agnes Manor directly. There is no cost for this service. We are compensated by the community you select.
Are you an owner or operator of Mary Agnes Manor?
Claim this listing to receive messages from prospective customers and manage your community page.