Mother Angeline McCrory Manor

    5199 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43213
    • Independent Living
    • Assisted Living
    • Memory Care
    • Skilled Nursing

    Compassionate staff and excellent rehab

    I'm very pleased with this faith-based community - the staff are friendly, compassionate and hands-on, and nurses, aides and PT/OT delivered excellent, effective rehab. The facility is beautiful and immaculate, meals are wonderful, and there are plenty of activities plus a lovely chapel and courtyard. Administration and admitting were responsive and supportive; I would highly recommend it.

    Current/former resident
    Jul 2026

    Schedule a Tour

    Date of Tour
    Time Window
    Tour Type

    You selected in-person tour on in the

    Amenities

    Healthcare services

    • Activities of daily living assistance
    • Assistance with bathing
    • Assistance with dressing
    • Assistance with transfers
    • Medication management
    • Mental wellness program

    Healthcare staffing

    • 12-16 hour nursing
    • 24-hour call system
    • 24-hour supervision

    Meals and dining

    • Diabetes diet
    • Meal preparation and service
    • Restaurant-style dining
    • Special dietary restrictions

    Room

    • Air-conditioning
    • Cable
    • Fully furnished
    • Housekeeping and linen services
    • Kitchenettes
    • Private bathrooms
    • Telephone
    • Wifi

    Transportation

    • Community operated transportation
    • Transportation arrangement
    • Transportation arrangement (non-medical)

    Common areas

    • Beauty salon
    • Computer center
    • Dining room
    • Fitness room
    • Gaming room
    • Garden
    • Outdoor space
    • Small library
    • Wellness center

    Community services

    • Concierge services
    • Fitness programs
    • Move-in coordination

    Activities

    • Community-sponsored activities
    • Planned day trips
    • Resident-run activities
    • Scheduled daily activities

    Reviews

    3.88·(78)

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      3.8
    • Staff

      3.8
    • Meals

      4.1
    • Amenities

      4.5
    • Value

      1.0

    Pros

    • Compassionate nursing and caregiving staff
    • Strong physical and occupational therapy programs
    • Home-like, well-maintained facility environment
    • Clean, attractive rooms and common areas
    • Engaging spiritual and faith-based programming
    • Varied activities and social programming
    • Appealing dining options and on-site cafeterias
    • Supportive social-work and discharge coordination
    • Secure outdoor courtyard and recreational spaces
    • Successful rehabilitation outcomes and returns home
    • Warm admission and front-desk personnel
    • Resident-centered atmosphere and dignity focus

    Cons

    • Inconsistent staffing levels and reliance on agency personnel
    • Variable management responsiveness and accountability
    • Communication gaps between nursing, administration, and families
    • Gaps in clinical care coordination (medication, pain, catheter, wound care)
    • Weak fall-prevention and transfer-safety practices
    • Limited dementia-specific training and engagement programming
    • Inconsistent availability of equipment and medical supplies
    • Sanitation and odor concerns in specific areas
    • Pest-control concerns in some units
    • Inconsistent privacy and information-handling practices
    • Variable visitation policy flexibility and spiritual-care availability
    • Incomplete personal property and laundry management
    • Gaps in escalation and emergency-transfer processes

    Summary of reviews

    Mother Angeline McCrory Manor elicits strongly mixed impressions. Many families describe a warm, faith-based community with compassionate nursing and caregiving staff, strong rehabilitation services (PT/OT), attractive common areas, and an overall home-like environment. Food and dining options, on-site amenities, and regular spiritual and social programming are frequently noted as strengths. Across multiple accounts, therapy departments and hands-on rehabilitation are singled out for producing measurable patient progress and successful transitions home.

    Clinical quality impressions are mixed. Several reviews praise attentive nursing care and individualized attention, while others describe inconsistent clinical coordination — examples include delayed symptom control, variable medication and catheter handling, inconsistent vital-sign monitoring, and gaps in wound- and infection-related follow-up. There are repeated references to issues with timely escalation and emergency-transfer processes. These contrasting accounts suggest the facility can provide high-quality care when staffing, communication, and clinical oversight align, but that care reliability may vary across units and shifts.

    Staff culture and training show a similar split. Many reviewers characterize staff as caring, patient, and family-oriented; cooks, housekeeping, and administrative personnel are often mentioned as becoming part of the family circle. At the same time, reviews indicate high turnover, reliance on temporary agency staff, language barriers with some aides, and instances of unprofessional conduct at the point of admission or front desk. There are consistent indications of a need for additional dementia-specific training and for improved strategies to engage residents with cognitive impairment beyond passive activities.

    Activities, dining, and facilities receive frequent praise. The facility is described as clean, thoughtfully designed, and peaceful, with an enclosed courtyard, chapel, multiple dining areas, snack stations, and a welcoming lobby. Programming includes religious services, social events, and entertainment. A contrasting thread is that residents with cognitive or behavioral needs sometimes experience insufficiently tailored engagement and that some residents spend extended periods with limited stimulation.

    Operational and administrative patterns of concern center on communication and consistency. Families report communication gaps between nursing and administration, intermittent failure to deliver promised supplies or equipment, unreliable personal-property and laundry handling, and inconsistent privacy/information practices. There are also mentions of sanitation and odor concerns in specific areas and isolated pest-control issues. Some reviews reference restrictive visitation practices and uneven availability of designated spiritual leaders, which is notable given the facility’s faith-based identity.

    Overall, the facility shows clear strengths in rehabilitation, therapeutic programming, spiritual life, and in many cases compassionate direct care. However, variability in staffing, training, supply reliability, clinical coordination, and management follow-through appears to drive the negative experiences. Prospective residents and families should verify current staffing patterns, dementia-care training, fall-prevention and escalation protocols, equipment/supply availability, and communication processes during tours and admissions discussions to assess whether those operational elements meet their expectations.

    Reviews written on Mirador

    We have no reviews to show about Mother Angeline McCrory Manor.

    Help other families by writing a review about your experience with this community.

    Medicare Ratings

    1·/ 5
    • Overall

    • Health Inspection

    • Staffing

    • Quality Measures

    Ratings from the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (Care Compare). View on Medicare.gov

    Location

    Map showing location of Mother Angeline McCrory Manor

    Mother Angeline McCrory Manor is located at 5199 E Broad St, Columbus, OH, 43213.

    About Mother Angeline McCrory Manor

    Mother Angeline McCrory Manor stands out with its wide open front lobby where there's a grand piano and a fireplace, along with plenty of seating, puzzles, games, and books for people to enjoy, and guests can use free Wi-Fi, which comes in handy when family or friends visit, especially since the entrance drive and conference rooms make it easy for group gatherings, family visits, or quiet meals together. The facility covers a lot of ground with its skilled nursing and intermediate care for residents who are very frail or need daily nursing help, and there are short-term rehabilitation services for those who need help getting back on their feet after a hospital stay, so people can expect physical, occupational, and speech therapy as part of what's offered. On top of all that, the manor includes assisted living, independent living, and memory care assisted living, which means folks with Alzheimer's or dementia can live in a setting focused on their needs, and the community stays active with scheduled daily recreational activities. Medical care is a priority, with services for things like ophthalmology and dermatology, and at the same time, spiritual support is available for anyone who wants it, since the Carmelite Sisters for the Aged and Infirm sponsor the manor and stay involved in daily life, because they believe in taking care of the whole person. People who live here can expect care plans suited to their health, along with a safe, home-like environment, and though the facility does a lot to make life comfortable, it sticks to simple comforts and personal touches-whether that means a game in the lobby, a therapy appointment, or some quiet time by the fireplace.

    People often ask...

    Mother Angeline McCrory Manor offers independent living, assisted living, memory care, and skilled nursing.

    There are 13 photos of Mother Angeline McCrory Manor on Mirador.

    Yes, Mother Angeline McCrory Manor allows residents to age in place and adjust their level of care as needed.

    The full address for this community is 5199 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43213.

    No, Mother Angeline McCrory Manor does not offer respite care. Respite care in assisted living communities provides temporary, short-term relief for primary caregivers by offering professional care for their loved ones. It allows individuals to stay in an assisted living community for a limited time, giving caregivers a break while ensuring residents receive necessary support and assistance with daily activities.

    Disclaimer

    Mirador Living is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of Mother Angeline McCrory Manor. The information above has not been verified or approved by the owner or operator. For exact information, please contact Mother Angeline McCrory Manor directly. There is no cost for this service. We are compensated by the community you select.

    Are you an owner or operator of this community?

    Claim this listing to receive messages from prospective customers and manage your community page.

    Nearby Communities

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 103 facilities$4,325/mo
    2. 104 facilities$4,136/mo
    3. 64 facilities$3,749/mo
    4. 98 facilities$4,642/mo
    5. 88 facilities$4,490/mo
    6. 70 facilities$3,873/mo
    7. 82 facilities$4,571/mo
    8. 42 facilities$5,049/mo
    9. 148 facilities$5,018/mo
    10. 12 facilities$2,940/mo
    11. 39 facilities$3,925/mo
    12. 29 facilities$6,393/mo
    © 2026 Mirador Living