Story Cottage Living

    13633 Carey Rd, Carmel, IN 46033
    • Assisted Living
    • Memory Care

    Small home, attentive, personalized care

    I'm very pleased with this small, 10-resident home - clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully designed for residents. The low resident-to-caregiver ratio shows: attentive, competent, and kind staff (manager Kristen truly goes above and beyond), delicious meals, and lots of home-style activities. My loved one is thriving with personalized, trustworthy care in a warm, welcoming atmosphere, and I recommend this place.

    Loved one of resident
    Jul 2026

    Schedule a Tour

    Date of Tour
    Time Window
    Tour Type

    You selected in-person tour on in the

    Reviews

    4.87·(15)

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      5.0
    • Staff

      5.0
    • Meals

      5.0
    • Amenities

      5.0
    • Value

      4.9

    Pros

    • Care-focused staff
    • Low resident-to-caregiver ratio
    • Attentive and compassionate caregivers
    • Individualized, excellent care
    • Wide variety of activities and events
    • Special seasonal programming (e.g., Christmas party with carolers, treats, hot chocolate)
    • Family-friendly environment and open visiting
    • Small, intimate community (10-resident capacity)
    • Beautiful, well-designed house and comfortable common areas
    • Home-style, laid-back atmosphere
    • Reliable and trustworthy caregivers
    • Staff who know residents' personal stories
    • Cleanliness and top-tier maintenance
    • Delicious meals
    • Strong, engaged management (manager Kristen highlighted)
    • Memory care done in a non-institutional, individualized way
    • High resident/family satisfaction and strong recommendations
    • Inclusive community with life-enriching programming
    • Residents appear to be thriving in the setting

    Cons

    • Communication and pay issues mentioned
    • Small community size may not suit families seeking larger social environments
    • Non-traditional dementia model (not a regular dementia unit) may not fit all care expectations

    Summary of reviews

    Overall sentiment across the reviews is overwhelmingly positive, portraying Story Cottage Living as a small, intimate memory-care residence where individualized attention and a home-like atmosphere are central strengths. Multiple reviewers highlight that the facility’s low resident-to-caregiver ratio (noted repeatedly as a 10-resident capacity) results in attentive, compassionate, and competent caregivers who genuinely know residents and their stories. The care is described as excellent, top-tier, and life-changing for some families, with many reviewers strongly recommending the community.

    Staff and management receive consistent praise. Caregivers are characterized as kind, trustworthy, and reliable, and reviewers repeatedly note the emotional connection and mutual enjoyment between staff and residents. Management is singled out for going above and beyond—one reviewer specifically named manager Kristen for personalized touches such as individualized gifts for residents—while HR and leadership are described as knowing residents’ stories and investing in personal relationships. This all contributes to a sense of safety, comfort, and family orientation within the home.

    The physical environment and daily life aspects are also highlighted positively. Multiple comments mention a beautiful, well-designed house with comfortable common areas and strong cleanliness standards. Reviewers praise the dining—meals are described as delicious—and the variety of activities, including special seasonal events like a Christmas party with carolers, treats, and hot chocolate. The programming is seen as inclusive and engaging, with residents appearing to thrive socially and emotionally in this intimate setting rather than in a more institutional memory unit.

    Despite the many strengths, a few concerns appear in the summaries. One recurring negative is mention of communication and pay issues—details are sparse, but they are flagged across reviews and should be explored further by prospective families. The small 10-resident capacity, while repeatedly praised for enabling individualized care, may also be a drawback for those looking for a larger social environment with more residents and programming diversity. Additionally, reviewers note that Story Cottage Living is not a typical dementia unit; it uses a non-traditional, home-style memory care model that may not match every family’s expectations or needs.

    In summary, these reviews portray Story Cottage Living as an intimate, well-run memory care home with exceptional staff, high-quality individualized care, a warm and home-like environment, strong management engagement, appealing meals, and meaningful activities. The principal caveats to investigate further are the specific communication/pay issues mentioned and whether the small-scale, non-institutional model matches a particular resident’s clinical and social needs. Prospective residents and families should consider touring the home, meeting staff (including management), and asking targeted questions about communication practices, staffing/pay policies, and how the program addresses more advanced or specialized dementia needs to ensure the fit is right.

    Reviews written on Mirador

    We have no reviews to show about Story Cottage Living.

    Help other families by writing a review about your experience with this community.

    Location

    Map showing location of Story Cottage Living

    Story Cottage Living is located at 13633 Carey Rd, Carmel, IN, 46033.

    About Story Cottage Living

    Story Cottage Living provides memory care for people with Alzheimer's disease and other forms of dementia, and what makes these homes stand out is how small and quiet they are, because each house only has 8 to 10 residents, and you'll notice that most everything inside is set up to keep things clear and simple-like the special closets with just two clothing options so choosing something to wear doesn't become confusing. Caregivers are available around the clock, with a caregiver-to-resident ratio as low as 3-to-1 some days, and at their dedicated Carey Grove location in Carmel it's 4-to-1, meaning each person gets attention and support, and nurses and other medical professionals visit a couple of times a week to check on residents and lend a hand when needed, while Senior Home Companions play a major part in supporting everyone there, since they've been caring for seniors for over 30 years. Each house features fully furnished private bedrooms-though families can bring familiar furniture if that's helpful-and rooms include special safety features and bathroom designs that try to prevent falls or slips, while all doors stay secure with passcodes and there are systems to keep track of where everyone is, so folks don't wander off.

    These homes feel less like a big facility and more like a quiet, peaceful house, so families tend to feel at ease knowing their loved one's in a setting where people know each other well, and there's a nice big living room, a sunroom that closes off for family visits, a library that also works as a nurse's station, and a patio where folks can get some fresh air, or maybe sit together in the salon area. Meals come from a dedicated chef, who prepares tasty and healthy dishes, and every day, the staff tries to keep everyone engaged with activities that feel personal and enjoyable, since the team gets to know each resident really well.

    Because of the way the houses are built, with only a handful of residents and a staff trained to work with those living with memory loss, routines stay predictable and comforting, which helps to limit confusion or distress, and the whole place tries to be as much like home as possible-whether that means letting people bring furniture from home or having gathering spaces that families can close off when they come to visit. Story Cottage Living runs several locations around Indianapolis, Carmel, West Clay, and Williams Creek, and besides the care they give, they've got resources for families too, like a decision toolkit, a blog and video library about dementia care, and a virtual tour so people can look around before deciding, and their homes stand in nice quiet neighborhoods, so there's a sense of peace and safety throughout the day. The staff, including a dedicated house manager with nursing experience, builds real relationships with residents, gives care that fits each person, and offers safety and help for families looking for a small and predictable memory care setting.

    People often ask...

    Story Cottage Living offers assisted living and memory care.

    There are 27 photos of Story Cottage Living on Mirador.

    The full address for this community is 13633 Carey Rd, Carmel, IN 46033.

    No, Story Cottage Living does not offer respite care. Respite care in assisted living communities provides temporary, short-term relief for primary caregivers by offering professional care for their loved ones. It allows individuals to stay in an assisted living community for a limited time, giving caregivers a break while ensuring residents receive necessary support and assistance with daily activities.

    Disclaimer

    Mirador Living is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of Story Cottage Living. The information above has not been verified or approved by the owner or operator. For exact information, please contact Story Cottage Living directly. There is no cost for this service. We are compensated by the community you select.

    Are you an owner or operator of this community?

    Claim this listing to receive messages from prospective customers and manage your community page.

    Nearby Communities

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 61 facilities$5,320/mo
    2. 134 facilities$5,837/mo
    3. 35 facilities$5,651/mo
    4. 113 facilities$5,853/mo
    5. 50 facilities$5,741/mo
    6. 89 facilities$6,368/mo
    7. 88 facilities$6,368/mo
    8. 89 facilities$6,345/mo
    9. 61 facilities$5,808/mo
    10. 9 facilities$6,012/mo
    11. 44 facilities$5,335/mo
    12. 25 facilities$6,106/mo
    © 2026 Mirador Living