Story Cottage Living

    13633 Carey Rd, Carmel, IN 46033
    • Assisted Living
    • Memory Care

    Request a Tour

    Date of Tour
    Time Window
    Tour Type

    You selected in-person tour on in the

    Reviews

    4.89·(18)

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Care

      5.0
    • Staff

      5.0
    • Meals

      5.0
    • Amenities

      5.0
    • Value

      4.9

    Pros

    • Dementia-trained caregiving staff
    • Low resident-to-staff ratio (small-house model)
    • Compassionate, personalized care
    • Engaging activities and family events
    • Delicious, home-style meals
    • Immaculate cleanliness and maintenance
    • Well-designed, comfortable cottages and common areas
    • Open visiting policy and family-friendly atmosphere
    • Responsive, hands-on management
    • Strong staff continuity and resident familiarity
    • Safe, intimate memory-care setting
    • Positive impact on resident well-being

    Cons

    • Limited bed capacity and potential waitlist constraints
    • Operational dependence on key staff or managers
    • Occasional HR/communication and payroll issues
    • Limited transparency about formal clinical and medication-management practices

    Summary of reviews

    The reviews portray Story Cottage Living as a small, home-like memory-care provider that emphasizes individualized attention. The facility’s small-house model (around ten residents) and low resident-to-staff ratio are repeatedly highlighted as central strengths: caregivers are described as compassionate, dementia-trained, and familiar with residents’ histories and preferences. Reviewers commonly attribute improved mood and daily engagement among residents to this personalized approach.

    Dining and housekeeping are frequently praised. Meals are described as home-style and appealing, and the cottages and common areas are consistently characterized as clean, comfortable, and well-maintained. Activity programming appears varied and family-oriented — examples include seasonal events (a Christmas party with carolers and treats), inclusive family gatherings, and routine social programming — which reviewers frame as contributing to an uplifting atmosphere.

    Staffing and management receive strong positive attention. Multiple accounts describe responsive, attentive management and hands-on leadership that personalizes gifts and attends to family communication. Reviewers emphasize staff continuity and an environment where caregivers know residents’ stories, which supports consistent, relationship-based care. The setting is described as safe and welcoming, with an open visiting approach that families appreciate.

    Notable patterns of caution include a few operational-level issues. The small capacity that is central to the cottage model can also limit availability and create waitlist constraints for prospective residents. Several comments imply an operational reliance on specific staff or managers; turnover or the loss of key personnel could have an outsized impact on daily operations. There are isolated mentions of HR/communication and payroll concerns that suggest internal administrative processes may occasionally be a source of friction. Finally, while reviewers emphasize high-quality hands-on care, there is limited public detail in the reviews about formal clinical protocols and medication-management practices; families seeking a higher level of clinical transparency may want to request those documents during a tour.

    Overall, the pattern across summaries is one of consistently positive family experience tied to a very small, relationship-driven memory-care model. Prospective residents and families prioritizing personalized attention, a comfortable home environment, engaging social programming, and consistent caregiving are likely to view Story Cottage Living favorably. Those who require immediate placement, want extensive institutional-scale clinical documentation, or are concerned about continuity if key leaders change should discuss those specific points with management before deciding.

    Reviews written on Mirador

    We have no reviews to show about Story Cottage Living.

    Help other families by writing a review about your experience with this community.

    Location

    Story Cottage Living is located at 13633 Carey Rd, Carmel, IN, 46033.

    About Story Cottage Living

    Story Cottage Living provides memory care for people with Alzheimer's disease and other forms of dementia, and what makes these homes stand out is how small and quiet they are, because each house only has 8 to 10 residents, and you'll notice that most everything inside is set up to keep things clear and simple-like the special closets with just two clothing options so choosing something to wear doesn't become confusing. Caregivers are available around the clock, with a caregiver-to-resident ratio as low as 3-to-1 some days, and at their dedicated Carey Grove location in Carmel it's 4-to-1, meaning each person gets attention and support, and nurses and other medical professionals visit a couple of times a week to check on residents and lend a hand when needed, while Senior Home Companions play a major part in supporting everyone there, since they've been caring for seniors for over 30 years. Each house features fully furnished private bedrooms-though families can bring familiar furniture if that's helpful-and rooms include special safety features and bathroom designs that try to prevent falls or slips, while all doors stay secure with passcodes and there are systems to keep track of where everyone is, so folks don't wander off.

    These homes feel less like a big facility and more like a quiet, peaceful house, so families tend to feel at ease knowing their loved one's in a setting where people know each other well, and there's a nice big living room, a sunroom that closes off for family visits, a library that also works as a nurse's station, and a patio where folks can get some fresh air, or maybe sit together in the salon area. Meals come from a dedicated chef, who prepares tasty and healthy dishes, and every day, the staff tries to keep everyone engaged with activities that feel personal and enjoyable, since the team gets to know each resident really well.

    Because of the way the houses are built, with only a handful of residents and a staff trained to work with those living with memory loss, routines stay predictable and comforting, which helps to limit confusion or distress, and the whole place tries to be as much like home as possible-whether that means letting people bring furniture from home or having gathering spaces that families can close off when they come to visit. Story Cottage Living runs several locations around Indianapolis, Carmel, West Clay, and Williams Creek, and besides the care they give, they've got resources for families too, like a decision toolkit, a blog and video library about dementia care, and a virtual tour so people can look around before deciding, and their homes stand in nice quiet neighborhoods, so there's a sense of peace and safety throughout the day. The staff, including a dedicated house manager with nursing experience, builds real relationships with residents, gives care that fits each person, and offers safety and help for families looking for a small and predictable memory care setting.

    People often ask...

    Story Cottage Living offers assisted living and memory care.

    There are 27 photos of Story Cottage Living on Mirador.

    The full address for this community is 13633 Carey Rd, Carmel, IN 46033.

    No, Story Cottage Living does not offer respite care. Respite care in assisted living communities provides temporary, short-term relief for primary caregivers by offering professional care for their loved ones. It allows individuals to stay in an assisted living community for a limited time, giving caregivers a break while ensuring residents receive necessary support and assistance with daily activities.

    Disclaimer

    Mirador Living is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of Story Cottage Living. The information above has not been verified or approved by the owner or operator. For exact information, please contact Story Cottage Living directly. There is no cost for this service. We are compensated by the community you select.

    Are you an owner or operator of Story Cottage Living?

    Claim this listing to receive messages from prospective customers and manage your community page.

    Nearby Communities

    Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

    1. 64 facilities$5,320/mo
    2. 142 facilities$5,837/mo
    3. 35 facilities$5,651/mo
    4. 123 facilities$5,853/mo
    5. 51 facilities$5,741/mo
    6. 99 facilities$6,368/mo
    7. 100 facilities$6,368/mo
    8. 101 facilities$6,345/mo
    9. 63 facilities$5,808/mo
    10. 9 facilities$6,012/mo
    11. 45 facilities$5,335/mo
    12. 26 facilities$6,106/mo
    © 2026 Mirador Living