The best assisted living facilities in Fire Island, NY

    Explore 8 communities near Fire Island, NY

    What's your price range?

    —
    Apply

    Filter by community type

    Independent Living

    For older adults who want to enjoy a carefree retirement in a community of their peers

    Assisted Living

    For seniors who may need some help with daily activities

    Memory Care

    A safe, supervised community supporting people living with dementia

    Skilled Nursing

    For seniors with more serious medical needs who require skilled care following a hospitalization, illness, or surgery.

    Continuing Care Retirement Communities

    For seniors who want to age in place as their care needs evolve, offering everything from independent living to full nursing care.

    Board And Care Homes

    Homes in residential neighborhoods providing daily care for a small number of residents

    All Senior Living Options

    Recommended
    Highest price
    Lowest price
    Best rated
    1. Entrance of Luxor at Sayville Rehabilitation & Nursing Center with a black canopy displaying the facility's name. The building exterior features large glass windows and black pillars, with a sidewalk and some greenery visible nearby.
      Pricing on request3.8 (253)
      suite
      assisted living, memory care, skilled nursing

      Luxor at Sayville Rehabilitation & Nursing Center

      300 Broadway Ave, Sayville, NY, 11782
    2. A bright and clean room with two beds covered in red and white patterned bedspreads. Between the beds are two wooden nightstands with flower arrangements. At the far end of the room is a large window with blinds and a valance, flanked by two chairs with red cushions and a small round table with books. There are framed botanical prints on the walls and a tall green plant in the corner.
      Pricing on request3.2 (195)
      suite
      assisted living, memory care, skilled nursing

      Affinity Skilled Living and Rehabilitation

      305 Locust Ave, Oakdale, NY, 11769
    3. $4,457 – $5,348+
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom
      independent living, assisted living

      Pleasant Gardens Adult Home

      396 Middle Rd, Bayport, NY, 11705
    4. Photo of Village Walk Senior Living
      $5,350 – $6,420+4.6 (79)
      Semi-private • 1 Bedroom
      assisted living, memory care

      Village Walk Senior Living

      131 E Main St, Patchogue, NY, 11772
    5. Pricing on request
      suite
      assisted living

      Heartland on the Bay, Inc.

      86 Blue Point Ave., Blue Point, NY, 11715
    6. Entrance to a building with double glass doors framed by white columns and a small roof. In front of the entrance is a tiered stone fountain with water flowing, surrounded by various plants and shrubs. The building exterior features a mix of stone and siding.
      $5,200 – $8,700+4.5 (93)
      Studio
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      The Bristal Assisted Living at Sayville

      129 Lakeland Ave, Sayville, NY, 11782
    7. Pricing on request4.1 (17)
      suite
      assisted living, memory care, skilled nursing

      Good Samaritan Nursing Home

      101 Elm St, Sayville, NY, 11782
    8. Exterior view of a multi-story senior living facility with a mix of brick and siding facades, balconies, and a central entrance with a covered drop-off area. The building is surrounded by landscaped gardens with flowers, trees, and a flagpole flying the American flag. A few cars are parked in front and a person is walking on the sidewalk.
      Pricing on request4.6 (185)
      suite
      independent, assisted living, memory care

      Brightview

      445 Broadway Ave, Sayville, NY, 11782
    1. Home
    2. Assisted Living
    3. New York
    4. Fire Island

    Cost of assisted living in Fire Island, New York

    Studio1 Bedroom2 BedroomsSemi-Private
    Independent Living$6,367$5,348—$4,457
    Assisted Living$6,367$5,348—$4,457
    Memory Care$6,367———

    * Prices shown are average monthly costs within a 20-mile radius

    Consider other types of facilities in Fire Island, NY

    • Independent Living

      For older adults who want to enjoy a carefree retirement in a community of their peers

    • Memory Care

      A safe, supervised community supporting people living with dementia

    • Skilled Nursing

      For seniors with more serious medical needs who require skilled care following a hospitalization, illness, or surgery.

    • Board And Care Homes

      Homes in residential neighborhoods providing daily care for a small number of residents

    • Continuing Care Retirement Communities

      For seniors who want to age in place as their care needs evolve, offering everything from independent living to full nursing care.

    Company

    Senior living guides

    © 2025 Mirador Living